Supreme Court: "Unreasonable Rent Demands Constitute Interference"
Orders Retrial on Damages Claim After Overturning Appellate Court

If a landlord demands more than three times the previous deposit and monthly rent from a prospective new tenant, and this causes the contract to fall through, the landlord can be held liable for damages for interfering with the existing tenant's right to recover the key money (goodwill premium), according to a recent Supreme Court decision.

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

According to the legal community on August 30, the First Division of the Supreme Court (Presiding Justice Cheon Dae-yeop) recently overturned a lower court ruling that dismissed A, a commercial tenant's, claim for damages against landlord B for interfering with the recovery of key money, and remanded the case to the Busan District Court.


Since 2001, A had operated a pharmacy in a commercial building owned by B. As the lease was set to expire in December 2023, A arranged for a new tenant. A signed a key money contract worth 2.2 billion won with the prospective tenant, but B demanded a new lease with a deposit of 500 million won and monthly rent of 20 million won—an increase of approximately 333% over the previous deposit of 100 million won and rent of 6 million won. The deal ultimately collapsed. A, claiming to have lost the key money, filed a lawsuit seeking damages from B.


Both the first and second trial courts ruled in B's favor. They dismissed A's claim for damages, stating that A had failed to sufficiently prove that B's demands for rent and deposit were “excessively high” as defined by the Commercial Building Lease Protection Act.


However, the Supreme Court took a different view. The justices noted that B’s demands were 3.3 times higher than the previous terms, making it highly probable that the amounts were “excessively high”; therefore, the lower courts should have properly reviewed the matter—including obtaining an appropriate market appraisal—to determine whether B was liable for damages.



The justices stated, “Whether the rent and deposit are excessively high should be judged by specifically considering local market prices, the appropriate rent, and trading practices,” and added: “There is ample room to consider the requested amount, which is 3.3 times the previous terms, as excessively high. The lower courts erred in law by rejecting the damages claim without fully examining these factors.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing