Temporary Domestic Violence Order Violations Exceed 1,000 for the First Time
Restraining Order Violations Increase Despite Tougher Penalties
"Criticized for Delays When Reacting, Blamed for Overreacting When Acting in Advance"

#. On August 23 in Seogwipo, Jeju, a man in his 50s, referred to as Mr. A and a former police officer, murdered his wife. Mr. A had been committing domestic violence since 2023, and in August of last year, he was arrested by the police for detaining and assaulting his wife. However, the detention warrant requested by the police at the time was dismissed by the court. Instead, as a temporary measure, he was banned from approaching or contacting his wife. After the temporary order, his wife applied for a restraining order, but Mr. A ignored the order and committed the crime.


#. In June this year, in Yangcheon-gu, Seoul, a woman in her 20s identified as Ms. B, violated a temporary restraining order and broke into the home of her common-law partner, threatening him with a weapon before being arrested. This time, the police also determined Ms. B to be a high-risk perpetrator of relationship-based crime and requested a detention warrant, but the prosecution rejected it. Despite a restraining order on her residence, there were no measures in place to prevent Ms. B from going to her partner and wielding a weapon.


ChatGPT-generated image.

ChatGPT-generated image.

View original image

Court-ordered restraining orders against perpetrators of domestic violence are being breached an average of four times per day. Although the penalty for violating temporary orders has been strengthened to imprisonment, the number of violations has more than doubled. There are calls to address institutional limitations that make it difficult to detect repeated access by offenders before a report is made by victims.


According to the National Police Agency as of August 31, there were 1,379 cases of violations of the first, second, and third types of temporary orders against domestic violence perpetrators last year, based on a provisional tally. This amounts to an average of four violations per day. Compared to 370 cases in 2020, the number has nearly quadrupled in five years. Under the Act on the Punishment of Domestic Violence Crimes, temporary orders are composed of Type 1, which expels or isolates the perpetrator from the victim's residence to prevent recidivism; Type 2, which bans the perpetrator from approaching within 100 meters of the victim; and Type 3, which prohibits approach using telecommunications such as phone calls or text messages. If necessary, the perpetrator can also be detained in a police holding cell or detention center.


However, restraining orders have difficulty preemptively stopping sudden repeat approaches. Unlike electronic monitoring such as GPS tracking anklets, it is not possible to check the perpetrator's location in real time. In many cases, police only become aware of temporary order violations after the victim files another report.


Back to the Victim's Side... Four Violations of 'Domestic Violence Restraining Orders' Per Day View original image

Notably, even after penalties for violating temporary orders were strengthened to include imprisonment, a steep increase in violations has continued. Compared to the 531 cases in 2021, the number has more than doubled in just four years.


With the amendment to the Act on the Punishment of Domestic Violence Crimes in January 2021, penalties for violating temporary orders were strengthened from a previous maximum fine of 5 million won to imprisonment of up to one year, or a fine or detention of up to 10 million won. The scope of restraining orders was also expanded to within 100 meters from specific locations such as the places of residence or employment of the victim and their family members. While the law was revised to allow for criminal punishment, it became clear that there were limitations to relying solely on ex post enforcement.


Even when the police—who are the first responders to domestic violence crimes—activate all possible protection measures, it is not enough to completely block impulsive approaches by perpetrators. A police official said, "Restraining orders are more like a step-by-step control measure before moving on to stronger measures," adding, "It is not feasible to preemptively restrict the physical freedom of all perpetrators." Another police official explained, "Although the response to relationship-based crimes is being strengthened, the threshold for courts or prosecutors to issue detention warrants is still high. If an incident occurs, we are criticized for slow response; if we take strong action in advance, we are criticized for overreacting. This creates a significant dilemma on the ground."



Amendments that would allow for adding GPS tracking anklets to temporary domestic violence orders and impose aggravated punishment for habitual violations of restraining orders and temporary measures are currently pending in the National Assembly. There are opinions that measures such as electronic monitoring anklets should be applied with caution. Daekyung Kwak, professor of police administration at Dongguk University, said, "Strengthening electronic monitoring can help prevent repeat offenses, but since it is a measure that restricts physical freedom, building social consensus must come first. In order to increase the deterrent effect, there is also a need to clearly inform perpetrators of the specific penalties for violating restraining orders."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing