"No Need to Consult with the County"... Shinan Renewable Energy Foundation Criticized for Arbitrary Operations
Recruitment Notice Only Posted on Foundation Website Despite Claims to Hire Local Talent
Over 279 Million Won Provided Last Year Alone... Calls Grow for Transparency and Disclosure of Records
The Shinan Renewable Energy Foundation, a public institution established and funded by Shinan County in Gwangju Special City, Jeollanam-do, has come under criticism for pushing ahead with new staff recruitment during a transition in county administration without prior consultation with its supervising authority, Shinan County.
As the acting chairman system has persisted for an extended period, major decision-making processes such as staff recruitment, board operations, and the reappointment of executives have not been properly disclosed. This has fueled growing criticism that the foundation is being run more like a private business than as a true public foundation.
The foundation was established as a local public institution to promote the development of Shinan County’s renewable energy industry and the welfare of its residents. Since both its basic assets and operating funds come from allocations by Shinan County, transparent management in accordance with relevant laws, ordinances, articles of incorporation, and operational guidelines for local public institutions is required, along with accountability to local residents.
This means that, although the foundation operates as an independent legal entity, it cannot escape from Shinan County’s oversight and the scrutiny of the county council.
The most contentious issue has been the new staff recruitment. The foundation posted a hiring announcement on June 24 and closed applications on June 30. The schedule continued with the announcement of document screening results on July 1, interviews on July 2, and the final list of successful candidates on July 3.
Unlike last year, when the recruitment notice was posted both on the Shinan County Office website and the foundation’s website, this year it was only published on the foundation’s website. Whereas recruitment announcements typically lasted for about two weeks, this recent posting was up for just seven days.
The foundation has explained this as an “emergency recruitment notice,” but critics have raised concerns that it amounts to “blind hiring.”
In particular, personnel and organizational guidelines for local public institutions require the institution’s head to notify the head of the local government of the necessity of recruitment, number of hires, current staffing status, qualifications, and screening methods prior to any public announcement.
Local governments are also required to review the appropriateness of recruitment plans submitted by institutions and communicate their findings in writing. As such, the key point of contention in this case is when the foundation notified Shinan County of its recruitment plans and what review opinions the county provided.
However, the foundation maintains that there was no need to consult with Shinan County regarding recruitment matters.
Kang Seong-gon, director-general and acting chairman of the Shinan Renewable Energy Foundation, told this newspaper by phone, “There is no need to consult with the county when hiring staff, and to date, we have never consulted with them during recruitment processes.”
He further explained, “Because salaries are low, even those who are hired often do not remain long in their positions. Operating on a minimum budget for wages creates many difficulties in workforce management.”
Nevertheless, possessing recruitment authority as a public institution and fulfilling the obligation to notify and undergo an appropriateness review by the supervising authority are entirely separate matters. Regardless of whether official approval was needed, it is imperative to verify that advance notification and review procedures specified in the guidelines were indeed carried out.
In particular, the foundation’s claim that “there is no need to consult with the county” is open to criticism for unduly minimizing the relationship of consultation and communication that a public institution, funded by Shinan County, should maintain with its supervising authority.
Questions have also been raised regarding the scale of personnel expenses.
According to this newspaper’s review of last year’s expenditures from county funding for the foundation, out of about 279 million won, approximately 157 million won was allocated to personnel expenses.
Assuming that three staff members worked for the foundation over the course of the year, the per-capita annual personnel expense amounts to about 53 million won.
Notably, this figure excludes various allowances and business expenses, suggesting that each individual’s actual annual salary may have been higher.
Given that the foundation has claimed “low salaries lead to staff resignations,” it is necessary to disclose detailed personnel expenditures—including base salary, allowances, severance pay, and employer contributions for the four major social insurances—to clarify any doubts.
The foundation has put forward an extensive set of medium- and long-term business plans: designating renewable energy special zones, establishing local energy plans, creating energy-independent islands among unconnected islands, developing resident-participation power generation projects, maintaining and repairing renewable energy facilities, fostering specialized offshore wind power personnel, and constructing education centers and energy hub centers.
However, there has not been sufficient disclosure of materials confirming the progress rate, actual expenditures, completion targets, or tangible outcomes for local residents for each project.
In contrast to its ambitious plans, there is a lack of information to objectively assess which projects the foundation has actually pursued, what results it has achieved, and how much it has contributed to the energy welfare and income of Shinan County residents.
Both Shinan County and its council must undertake a thorough review of the foundation’s overall management.
The foundation should publicly disclose advance recruitment notifications, county review results, information on current and target staff numbers, composition of review committees, and final selection results. In addition, meeting minutes of the board of directors, documents on the appointment and reappointment of executives, the basis and scope of the acting chairman's authority, detailed payroll expenditure records, project-by-project budget execution statements, management performance evaluation findings, and improvement plans should all be made available to county residents.
As a public institution funded by local taxpayers, the foundation should not merely assert its recruitment and project management authority. It must also provide evidence of proper procedures, documentation of sound budget execution, and concrete records of achievements made through its projects.
Above all, if the foundation continues to prioritize independence and refuses consultation and communication with its supervising authority, Shinan County, it risks undermining both the intent behind its establishment and its public character.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
If the foundation continues to disregard calls for information disclosure and responsible explanation, it will likely remain criticized not as “a specialized institution preparing for Shinan’s energy future,” but as “a closed organization with the trappings of a public institution.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.