“Give-and-Take” Basic Pension Structure Remains, Triggers Immediate Backlash
Proposal Abruptly Canceled One Hour Before Announcement; Possibility of Full Withdrawal Raised

The Ministry of Health and Welfare’s abruptly withdrawn proposal for basic pension reform, which was said to “offer greater support to the most vulnerable,” has revealed a structure where the actual increase in benefits is concentrated only among those whose income falls between 32% and 40% of the median. This is because, under the proposal, recipients of Basic Livelihood Support, who are in the lowest income group, would continue to see any increase in their pension offset by a corresponding reduction in their welfare benefits—a so-called “give-and-take basic pension” structure that has been neglected. As the specifics of this reform plan came to light, senior citizen groups have issued strong protests, fueling a rapidly growing controversy.

A citizen visiting the Comprehensive Counseling Office at the Seoul Northern Regional Headquarters of the National Pension Service is consulting with an employee. Photo by Yonhap News.

A citizen visiting the Comprehensive Counseling Office at the Seoul Northern Regional Headquarters of the National Pension Service is consulting with an employee. Photo by Yonhap News.

View original image

The Coalition for Guaranteeing Basic Pension Rights for Impoverished Seniors issued a statement on August 28, condemning the government by declaring, “It is expected that the number of seniors deprived of their rights due to the ‘give-and-take basic pension’ will approach 1 million over this year and next, but the government’s reform proposal contains no measures to address this. Even if the basic pension is deposited into beneficiary accounts on the 25th of each month, the same amount is deducted from their livelihood support on the 20th of the following month, meaning these seniors experience zero net increase in total income.” The coalition continued, “We are outraged by the welfare ministry’s reform plan, which mocks the very poorest seniors,” adding, “President Lee Jaemyung, do you really consider this a lower-tier basic pension? The government must completely redesign the proposal.”


The government’s proposed reform would change the eligibility threshold for the basic pension from the current “bottom 70% of income earners” to those under the “median income,” and gradually reduce the benefit coverage—from targeting 90% of the median income in 2027 to 80% by 2030. Under the new plan, individuals with income at or below 20% of the median would receive 400,000 won per month by 2028, those between 20% and 40% would receive 367,000 won per month (as of 2028), while those above 40% would see their pension frozen at the current rate of 350,000 won per month.


However, seniors in extreme poverty—those with income at or below 32% of the median, which qualifies for Basic Livelihood Support—would see no real benefit even if they receive the basic pension, because it is fully counted as recognized income and thus deducted from their welfare benefits. While this structural issue has been pointed out repeatedly, it was not addressed in the latest proposal. In 2025, of the 783,222 seniors who received both the basic pension and Basic Livelihood Support, 99.8% (781,561 people) saw their welfare benefit reduced. The average cut was 332,610 won, a figure nearly equal to the average basic pension payment (344,000 won).

"Excited for 400,000 Won" Turns to Anger: "It Feels Like an Insult" as Basic Pension Leaves Seniors with No Income Gain View original image

As a result, the only group to fully enjoy the benefit from this pension increase is those above the Basic Livelihood Support cut-off but still within the basic pension increase bracket: seniors with income above 32% and up to 40% of the median. Even among the “near-poor” population (those between 32% and 50% of the median income), only a limited portion will benefit. Meanwhile, the proposed narrowing of eligibility criteria has also become a focal point of criticism. The Korea Development Institute (KDI) has analyzed that if the benchmark is shifted to 100% of the median income, coverage would shrink to cover just 57% of all seniors by 2070. If the threshold is lowered to 80% within four years, coverage would shrink even more rapidly, making large-scale exclusion—and the backlash that comes with it—inevitable.



Meanwhile, the Ministry of Health and Welfare abruptly canceled a scheduled briefing on the reform plan, which had been set to be led in person by Minister Jeong Eun-kyeong, just one hour before it was to begin. The ministry stated only that “some aspects have not yet been finalized,” and has not announced any future briefing date. There are growing expectations both inside and outside the government that, due to concerns about potential loss of support among senior voters, a structure that benefits only select income brackets, and criticisms over secretive policymaking, the reform may either be indefinitely postponed or scrapped altogether.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing