If Students Use AI, It's Cheating; If Institutions Do, It's Innovation
The Power to Judge Has Changed
Automation Eliminates Even 'Inefficiency' in Entry-Level Jobs
The First Step Toward Skill Acquisition Disappears
Machines Grow More Human, Humans Adapt to the Machine
If you have been using the internet for a long time, you have probably been asked to pick out traffic lights or crosswalks. That's CAPTCHA. After selecting a few blurry photos and checking 'I am not a robot', you were done. For a test that separates humans from machines, it felt rather underwhelming. This was because we assumed that humans could recognize the context in a photo, while machines could not.
An image depicting cheating with 'AI Glasses' that show answers through artificial intelligence (AI) when looking at test questions. Recently, such cheating was detected even in national qualification exams, emerging as a new management challenge at testing sites.
View original imageThat belief is quickly becoming outdated. In June, cheating using glasses equipped with artificial intelligence was detected during a national qualification exam. When the user looked at an exam question, the AI would find the answer and display it on the glasses. Now, exam proctors must not only check whether the test-taker knows the answers, but also whether those answers truly came from them. The question exams used to ask—'Do you know?'—now comes with an added layer: 'Did you answer?'
The confusion faced by the publishing industry is similar. In the United States, the publication contract for a graduate student’s novel was canceled over suspicions that AI was used. The author countered that AI was only used for research and vocabulary checks. Meanwhile, there are new certifications marking works as "human-made content" to prove that a person authored them. In a time when a single author’s name is no longer enough, books now need proof that they are genuinely written by a human. If AI gathers the sources and a person does the writing, is it a human work? What about when a person drafts the text and AI does the editing? The line between what we have called a tool and what we have called an author is beginning to blur.
The situation is even stranger on the other side. Despite how automated AI tasks such as data classification, labeling, and content moderation appear, considerable human intervention is still required. The more perfect automation seems, the less visible this labor becomes. Researchers call this "ghost work." On one side, there are people who must make it look like AI did their job; on the other, there are people who have to present the work done by humans as if it were done by AI. The distinction between human and machine has gradually shifted to a question of "who actually did it?"
And now, even the role of judging is being supported by AI. In education, the use of AI for scoring written or essay-type answers is expanding. If a student uses AI to generate a response, it could be considered cheating. However, educational institutions using AI to grade students’ answers is being seen as a method of increasing efficiency. Yet, limitations have become clear, such as the tendency of AI scoring models to give higher marks to responses that heavily repeat the vocabulary from the presented materials.
What is even more interesting here is not machine error, but human response. Tests have always changed students. If the style of questioning changes, so do study methods. If AI becomes the grader, students will study not only 'good answers,' but also the 'answers that AI will grade highly.' When recruiting systems read resumes first, job seekers tailor their resumes for the algorithms. Adjusting the format of titles and videos for search and recommendation algorithms is now commonplace.
Humans are adaptive creatures. Whenever a new environment emerged, we survived by changing our behavior accordingly. There’s no reason it should be different in the age of AI. However, this time, the environment we must adapt to is also reading us, evaluating us, and ranking us. While we have worked to make machines more human-like, humans have started to adjust themselves in ways that are easier for machines to interpret. The problem is not that humans cannot adapt to AI—it is that we are adapting perhaps too well.
In the labor market, this adaptation may change the entire process of human growth. Analysts say that entry-level tasks that new hires have traditionally handled, such as organizing data, drafting basic documents, and beginner coding, could be replaced by AI. From a productivity perspective, this might seem positive. However, humans do not join companies as senior employees. New hires learn by performing simple tasks repeatedly, making mistakes, being corrected, and trying again—this is how they develop judgment. Corporations may see this as inefficiency, but for individuals, it is a process of acquiring skills. If we erase this inefficiency for the sake of productivity, where will we find skilled workers a few years down the road? Efficiency may accelerate outcomes, but whether it can compress the process of growth is still unknown.
A dozen years ago, solving a CAPTCHA—that was the end of distinguishing between man and machine. Now, humans use AI, AI evaluates humans, and humans change themselves to match those evaluations. Neither side has completely replaced the other; instead, their domains are mixing together. Rather than saying the line between human and machine is blurring, perhaps the more important changes are happening on the human side. We still check off "I am not a robot" without much thought. Yet while machines are becoming more human-like, humans are gradually changing into forms more recognizable to machines. Thus, the question has become a bit more complicated than it used to be.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Who are you?
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.