Custody and Restraining Order Disputed in Court

Abortion Rights at the Center of a National Debate

A custody battle between a biological mother and a surrogate over a baby born with a congenital heart defect has escalated into a legal dispute. While the biological mother requested an abortion, the surrogate proceeded with the birth. Public attention is now focused on the courtroom for what has been dubbed the "American Solomon's Judgment."


According to CNN on August 26 (local time), a hearing was held the previous day in a Dallas, Texas courthouse to determine the custody of the child and whether the restraining order against McKenna West, age 28, should remain in effect. West is the child's surrogate mother.


Meanwhile, the baby's biological mother, Naushin Gilkar, broke down in tears in court, saying, "That child is our baby." Gilkar explained that she had undergone eight rounds of in vitro fertilization and a hysterectomy before entering into a surrogacy contract. She said she did so because "it was my only option" to have a baby.


Surrogate MaKenna West conducting a video interview with an anti-abortion social organization. YouTube screenshot

Surrogate MaKenna West conducting a video interview with an anti-abortion social organization. YouTube screenshot

View original image

Gilkar said of West, "She is an unstable woman. She has been running with our baby from one doctor to another, and from one state to another," and claimed, "She is trying to take the child away from us."


In response, West asserted that she fled in order to protect the baby. Describing the abortion procedure, she said, "They would have injected medication to stop the baby’s heart. It’s truly horrific."


The biological parents named the baby Lumi, but West refers to the child as Gabriel. The judge decided that the baby will be called Lumi in accordance with the birth certificate.


The custody dispute over the newborn erupted around West’s 20th week of pregnancy, when the fetus was diagnosed with a congenital heart defect. After tests confirmed hypoplastic left heart syndrome, the biological mother requested an abortion. However, West refused and moved to Texas, where abortion is banned, ultimately giving birth to the baby on August 12.


The baby has since undergone surgery and is currently in the intensive care unit of a Dallas hospital. Without proper treatment, newborns with a malformed left ventricle face the risk of dying within weeks. The child will require a total of three surgeries before the age of five and remains at risk of additional complications.


Gilkar expressed anguish over the baby's deteriorating health: "The baby is struggling to breathe and unable to take in air. I had to watch as her throat was blocked by a tube."



This case has emerged as a politically and socially charged issue in the United States, intertwined with abortion rights. West has brought the legal fight into the public eye by refusing an abortion and has raised large sums of money under the banner of "the fight to save baby Gabriel’s life." Meanwhile, the court extended the restraining order against West, but did not render a decision regarding custody.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing