Vague Expectations That Damage the Economy, Healthcare, and Education
Side Effects from Reagan Tax Cuts and Medical Sector Conflicts
Numerous Loopholes as the Wealthy Exploit Policy Benefits
The Consequence of Using Science as "Policy Wrapp

[Insight & Opinion] The Trickle-Down Effect Is an Illusion: Money Is Not Water and the Economy Is Not Physics View original image

The global semiconductor boom, fueled by artificial intelligence (AI), is lifting the Korean economy. Semiconductor conglomerates, whose valuations have skyrocketed, are making headlines with large N% performance bonuses, and the government is reveling in a surge in tax revenue. There is a commotion over the government's plan to use the additional tax revenue to establish a vaguely defined fund for future preparedness, instead of paying down debt. The Korea Development Institute (KDI) has also raised its GDP growth forecast for this year to 3.2%. However, there is growing dissatisfaction over the limited trickle-down effect of the semiconductor boom. In fact, last month, semiconductor exports from large corporations increased by 228.3%, but exports by mid-sized companies related to semiconductors actually decreased by 13.4%. The impressive performance of semiconductor conglomerates is not spreading through the supply chain. Manufacturing sectors less connected to semiconductors, including material, parts, and equipment industries, are also struggling. As a result, the KDI has revised its forecast for the increase in the number of employed persons this year to 110,000, which is a 35% reduction from the May forecast of 170,000.

The trickle-down effect is often justified by the “law of gravity,” which holds true not just on Earth but throughout the universe. The core idea is that water, pulled by gravity, flows downward and spreads widely. The terraced rice paddies in Darangi Village, Namhae, South Gyeongsang Province—constructed stepwise on steep slopes near the coast—clearly demonstrate this effect. These terraced fields, painstakingly built by people forced to live and farm in mountainous regions with limited flat land, have become an analogy used to explain economic principles.


Of course, water flowing from high to low is a natural phenomenon determined by earth’s gravity. However, gravity does not always guarantee that water will spread widely. On the contrary, it is more common for small streams to merge and form major rivers like the Yangtze. Korea’s four major rivers all formed naturally due to gravity. It is hard to see why economics focuses on rare, artificial examples like terraced fields while ignoring such major rivers. Perhaps, like the terraced paddies, the trickle-down effect also requires active intervention and does not arise organically. An artificial "channel" is needed to ensure that capital flows to lower levels.


The trickle-down effect is not a mainstream economic theory. The original term was first used by American humorist Will Rogers during the Great Depression of the 1930s to criticize the economic policies of President Herbert Hoover, who was an engineer by training. In the 1980s, the phrase went viral through the media’s satirical coverage of President Ronald Reagan's tax cuts for the wealthy. Reaganomics, the idea that tax cuts for the rich would end up benefiting lower-income groups through a trickle-down effect, was called an illusion. There are few examples of its success, but many of failure. In 2012, the state of Kansas in the U.S. dramatically cut personal and corporate income taxes. The outcome was disastrous: tax revenues plunged, the state's credit rating was downgraded, and the expected increase in employment never came. In the end, the tax cuts were reversed in 2017. Sometimes, the trickle-down effect works in the opposite direction. When the top 20% of earners' income share increases by 1 percentage point, economic growth is 0.08 percentage point lower over the following five years. Conversely, when the bottom 20%’s income share rises, growth actually increases by 0.38 percentage point. This is according to a 2015 analysis by the International Monetary Fund (IMF).


The reasons for the absence of the trickle-down effect have also been identified. There are numerous, much more attractive “side routes” that the wealthy use to benefit from tax cuts. It is not due to moral hazard among the wealthy, but rather because it is institutionally impossible to regulate how surplus funds are used. We cannot force all wealthy individuals to follow the traditions and ethics of old aristocratic families. In the end, the trickle-down effect is nothing more than an empty slogan appealing to politicians and bureaucrats. We must remember the painful lesson that the government and politicians rely more heavily on the trickle-down effect the shakier their policies become.


[Insight & Opinion] The Trickle-Down Effect Is an Illusion: Money Is Not Water and the Economy Is Not Physics View original image

This lesson is not limited to economic policy. In fact, the gravity-anchored trickle-down effect has also hit the medical sector. The previous administration invoked the idea of the trickle-down effect as an excuse for reviving collapsing regional, public, and essential medical services. The argument was that increasing the admission quota for medical schools would resolve chronic issues in the medical sector by producing a surplus of doctors. In reality, however, the opposite occurred. The indispensable regional, public, and essential medical fields were branded, disparagingly, as recipients of “trickle-down healthcare.”


Interest in the trickle-down effect is also high in education. The Ministry of Education’s push for the “creation of 10 universities on par with Seoul National University” is also rooted in the trickle-down argument. The expectation is that if 10 regional flagship universities receive concentrated support to reach Seoul National University's level, other local universities will improve as well, resolving the excessive concentration around the capital area. However, even if the narrow admissions funnel is expanded into ten spacious, regionally distributed highways, the persistent overheating of university admissions and the rush toward medical schools will likely remain unchanged. Moreover, it seems the Ministry of Education will have to drastically scale back both the number and size of these “highways” for practical reasons. This suggests that university innovation policy is becoming a complete mess.


As David Hume pointed out, inferring a normative statement—what ought to be in society—from a factual statement—what actually is, as described by science—is fundamentally impossible. Science is indeed a useful tool for identifying the state of society, but it is unreasonable to expect science to tell us what our society should become. Science can be a tool for diagnosing reality, but not a wrapper for justifying socioeconomic, healthcare, or educational policies.


Applying physical laws—which allow no exceptions—to political, economic, and social issues must always be approached with caution. Laws, morals, customs, and markets governing social issues are full of exceptions we simply cannot ignore. In fact, sorting out these exceptions may be an even more urgent task.



Duckhwan Lee, Professor Emeritus at Sogang University, Science Communication


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing