"All Responsibilities and Costs Should Not Be Shifted to Small-Scale Dealers"

"Accountability Must Be Shared According to the Authority and Role of Inspectors, Insurers, and Platforms"

Used car dealers in the Gwangju area have called for a reexamination of the government’s used car consumer protection measures, stating, “While we agree with strengthening consumer rights, it is unacceptable to shift responsibilities and costs onto small-scale dealers.”


According to the industry on the 26th, the Gwangju Automobile Dealers Association recently issued a statement emphasizing that, “It is unreasonable to hold used car dealers primarily responsible for performance inspection errors and warranty liabilities when the companies that inspect vehicles and those that sell them are separate entities.”

Used cars for sale are lined up in a used car trading complex in the Gwangju area.

Used cars for sale are lined up in a used car trading complex in the Gwangju area.

View original image

On August 6, the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport announced measures for used car consumer protection following the 12th National Policy Coordination Meeting presided over by the Prime Minister. The main initiatives include mandatory display of the total price (sum of the vehicle price and fees), revamping the performance and condition inspection report, strengthening used car dealers’ liability for defect warranties, and addressing unfair practices on online auction platforms.


The plan is also to consolidate the existing performance inspectors’ insurance into mandatory insurance for dealers, and to allow contracts to be canceled under certain conditions if critical defects in major components are discovered within seven days after purchase.


The Gwangju association stated that it fully agrees fake or bait listings should be eliminated and that the transparency of transaction costs and vehicle condition should be ensured. However, as inspection, sales, insurance, and platform diagnostics are each handled by different parties, the association argued that responsibilities must be divided according to each role.


The performance and condition inspection report is the key document used by dealers to inform consumers of the vehicle’s status, but the actual inspections are carried out by separate inspection firms. The association therefore insisted that if an inspection company records information incorrectly or omits major defects, that company should bear initial responsibility.


There are also concerns that shifting defect warranty responsibility and insurance premium burdens onto dealers will worsen the financial difficulties of small businesses. Most local dealerships are small-scale businesses that lack their own inspection personnel or legal and insurance departments. If insurance and refund costs are added to vehicle purchasing, refurbishing, and advertising expenses, an increasing number of dealerships could be forced out of business.


The association also demanded the establishment of an independent diagnosis procedure to determine the cause of defects. In deciding whether to cancel a contract, the association argued that sub-regulations should include detailed standards that distinguish between defects inherent to the vehicle itself, driver negligence, or intentional damage by the consumer.


The association opposed a flat-rate adjustment of dealers’ insurance premiums to reflect costs from inspection errors, and insisted that insurance providers should instead exercise subrogation rights against inspection agencies when their fault is determined.


They also asserted that online platforms should bear responsibility if inaccurate diagnostic information provided by the platform leads to losses, and that if a sales agent’s intentional act or negligence results in consumer harm, there should be a legal basis for business owners to exercise claims against that individual.


Furthermore, the association suggested establishing an integrated electronic system for managing the complete employment histories of sales staff, to prevent employees with outstanding debts or unresolved consumer disputes from moving to other dealers, and having this system operated by the relevant federation. However, it added that measures must be created to ensure protection of personal information and business rights.


Baek Seonil, president of the Gwangju Automobile Dealers Association, stated, “Local dealers also share the view that we must create an environment where consumers can buy and sell used cars with confidence.” He added, “Performance inspection errors should be the responsibility of the inspector, diagnostic errors on platforms should be the responsibility of the platform, and issues related to insurance terms and compensation should be addressed by the insurer.”



He went on to say, “Dealers should of course be held liable for fake or bait listings, as well as deliberate concealment of defects. The foundation of the new measures must be the principle of ‘alignment between responsibility and action,’ where each party bears responsibility proportional to their authority and actions.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing