The Failure of a First Job Is a Structural Issue, Not a Personal One
Exceptions Uphold, Not Weaken, the Law's Principles
"A One-Time" Unemployment Benefit as the Minimum Safety Net

[Young Domain]The Decision to Quit: One Chance Is Necessary View original image

Not long ago, a peer asked me for advice. Having spent ten months at their job, they confessed that the work did not suit them at all and wanted to quit. However, they worried that if they resigned on their own, they would not be eligible to receive a single won in unemployment benefits. They were correct. The Employment Insurance Act stipulates that “involuntary termination” is a basic requirement for receiving job-seeker’s allowance. Those who voluntarily resign are, in principle, not protected. In the end, my friend has neither quit nor found another position, now filling their eleventh month at the company.


Recently, the government announced plans to create an exception to this principle. The proposal would allow people under the age of 35 to receive unemployment benefits once in their lifetime, even if they resign voluntarily after a certain period of employment. Measures reportedly under consideration include paying about 1 million KRW per month, or 60% of the previous wage. As soon as the proposal was announced, it drew criticism for encouraging moral hazard and sparked concerns that the employment insurance fund would be unable to handle the burden. Some of these concerns warrant serious consideration.


Nevertheless, this exception is worth making. The failure of a first job is not simply a matter of personal whim, but rather a structural issue. A first job is often chosen based on little more than a few job postings and one or two interviews, with no prior work experience or meaningful point of comparison. For a long time, the law has recognized that a contract where the party lacking information bears all the risk of the outcome is fundamentally unfair. Guaranteeing one opportunity in a lifetime to rebutton the first wrongly fastened button is not an act of charity; it is society collectively shouldering the risk created by structural problems.


The fear of moral hazard is overstated. Two out of every three people under 35 who resign voluntarily already leave before completing one year of service. This means that even without benefits, young people who feel they must leave are doing so. Conversely, a young person who has found a job that suits them is unlikely to abandon it just to claim a one-time unemployment payment.


The difference is not about leaving or not, but about “how” one leaves. Right now, young people often quit without preparation, take any available job during a period of unemployment, and then quit again, perpetuating a vicious cycle. The bare minimum of support will stop this revolving door and allow sufficient time to make a better choice for their next position. Forcing people to remain in unsuitable roles is, for the individual, the company, and the labor market as a whole, the most expensive waste.


From the perspective of someone of this same generation and as a legal professional, I believe this proposed amendment completes, rather than undermines, the core principle. The law upholds principles by allowing narrowly tailored exceptions. The intent behind the “involuntary termination” principle is to prevent abuse of insurance—so requirements such as “once in a lifetime” and “minimum length of service” have been included. There is no way to exploit this as a repeatable allowance. The purpose is protected by the principle; relief is provided through tightly defined conditions. This is what the law has always done. Of course, details such as how long one must be employed, verifying reemployment efforts, and differentiating the benefit level must be carefully designed. But this calls for refinement, not for shutting the door on reform altogether.


The fiscal impact should be taken seriously. However, the costs are not limited to what shows up on the bill. The cost of leaving mismatches unaddressed, forcing young people to drift in their careers, and allowing career gaps to accumulate into lifetime income losses—these may not always appear in the ledgers, but they do not disappear. If someone asks, “Aren’t you just helping those who leave by using the money of those who stick it out and pay insurance contributions?” I would answer: even for those who persevere, this exception is a right that they themselves may one day use. That is what insurance is—a promise to share each other’s risks.


In the drawer of the friend who has been enduring for eleven months, there is probably a half-written resignation letter. What they need is not an allowance to coax them out, but a bare minimum of time so that the next choice they make is not another failure. To ensure that this resignation becomes a prepared transition rather than a reckless escape, a “one-time exception” is well worth creating.



Lee Jaehong, Attorney

[Section: young域]
The Asia Business Daily welcomes articles from young writers with a diversity of thoughts and experiences. These pieces are published in [Section: young域] and widely shared. If you wish to contribute, please prepare a piece around 2,000 characters in length expressing your unique views and opinions, along with a brief self-introduction, and submit it to column@asiae.co.kr. After reviewing your submission, we will let you know if it will be published. Selected articles will appear both in print and online editions of The Asia Business Daily. A modest honorarium will be provided.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing