Production Workers’ Union Rejects Proposal, Office Workers’ Union Approves

Just 25-Vote Margin Separates Yes and No Votes in Production Workers’ Union

Details Such as Performance Bonus Payment Method Expected to Be Revisited

An SK hynix provisional labor-management wage and collective bargaining agreement (CBA)—centered on paying 60% of performance bonuses in company stock—was reached after two months of negotiations, but was rejected in a union vote, leading to renegotiations.


SK hynix’s production workers’ union announced on the 25th that the electronic vote on the tentative agreement, which concluded at 9 a.m. that day, resulted in 49.92% (7,510 votes) in favor and 50.08% (7,535 votes) opposed, resulting in a rejection. Out of a total 16,083 members, 15,045 participated, marking a turnout of 93.81%. Although more than half of all eligible members voted, the provisional agreement was rejected because the majority of participants voted against it. The difference between yes and no votes was 25. Voting was held from 6 a.m. on the 24th until 9 a.m. on the 25th.


In contrast, the technical and office workers’ union, which finished voting later that day, approved the provisional agreement with an acceptance rate of 66.2%, resulting in diverging outcomes between the two unions. However, since the office union has only about 1,000 members and conducted separate negotiations, industry observers expect its impact on renegotiations with the production workers’ union to be limited.


As a result, SK hynix and the production workers’ union must now revisit the direction of their negotiations. When talks resume, they are expected to focus once again on key issues, including the method of performance bonus payments. The SK hynix union also entered into renegotiations with management in both 2023 and 2024 after provisional agreements were rejected.


SK hynix Semiconductor Cluster Phase 1 Fab Construction Site in Cheoin-gu, Yongin, Gyeonggi Province. Photo by Jin-Hyung Kang

SK hynix Semiconductor Cluster Phase 1 Fab Construction Site in Cheoin-gu, Yongin, Gyeonggi Province. Photo by Jin-Hyung Kang

View original image

Previously, on August 20, after six rounds of talks, SK hynix labor and management drafted a tentative agreement that included a 6.3% wage increase and payment of 40% of the performance-based surplus sharing (PS) bonus in cash and the remaining 60% in company stock. Of the shares awarded, 40% could be sold the day after receipt, while the remaining 20% would be deferred: 10% paid each year over a two-year period. However, for the portion of the PS paid at the beginning of next year for 2026, recipients may opt to receive the stock equivalent of 40% in cash.


The close split between votes for and against suggests that union members are deeply divided over the agreement.


Some members expressed strong dissatisfaction that, only a year after labor and management agreed to maintain the existing bonus payment system for ten years, the company unilaterally shifted the structure from an all-cash payout to partial payment in company stock. While up to 80% of the bonus scheduled to be paid next year can be taken in cash, concerns were raised that the portion paid in stock could increase in subsequent years. Additional complaints emerged due to the risk that the actual value of the compensation could fluctuate based on stock price changes.



On the other hand, nearly half of unionized voters supported the proposal. The wage increase of 6.3% surpasses Samsung Electronics’ (6.2%), the fundamental structure of the existing performance bonus program remains intact—including the abolition of the cap on PS funds—and the option for up to 80% of next year’s payout to be received in cash was evaluated positively.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing