'Bribery Recording File' Secured During Fair Trade Act Investigation
No Additional Warrant Obtained
First Trial Guilty Verdict Overturned

Yonhap News

Yonhap News

View original image

The Supreme Court has made a final ruling that it is illegal for the prosecution to use a recorded file containing evidence of bribery, discovered by chance while executing a search and seizure warrant issued for 'bid collusion' charges, in investigation and trial without obtaining a separate warrant. Due to this procedural flaw in the prosecution's investigation, the review board members who were indicted for receiving tens of millions of won in kickbacks during the review process for projects commissioned by Korea Land and Housing Corporation (LH) were ultimately acquitted by the Supreme Court.


According to the legal community on the 26th, the Supreme Court (Presiding Justice Lee Heungku) upheld the lower court’s acquittal verdict in the appeal trial of Mr. A and Mr. B, who were indicted on charges of bribery. Mr. A participated as a bid evaluation committee member for construction project management services commissioned by LH in January 2020. He was brought to trial on charges of receiving a total of 70 million won from two competing firms in exchange for their request to be selected as service providers. Mr. B, who was also indicted, participated as a committee member at the same time and was accused of awarding the highest score to a company that had given him 20 million won while giving the third-highest score to a competing company.


The central issue in this case was whether to recognize the evidentiary value of the 'LH Evaluation Committee Member Disposition Analysis Report' and the recorded file containing details of bribery, which the prosecution presented as decisive evidence. The first trial found both individuals guilty, sentencing Mr. A to three years in prison, a 70 million won fine, and an additional 40 million won confiscation; and Mr. B to two years in prison, a 20 million won fine, and an additional 20 million won confiscation.


However, the decision was overturned in the appellate court. The appellate judges determined that the key evidence presented by the prosecution qualified as 'illegally obtained evidence' and thus acquitted both individuals. Initially, the prosecution executed the search and seizure warrant on suspicions of violations of the Fair Trade Act, such as bid collusion. During this process, the prosecution discovered the evaluation committee member disposition analysis report and the bribery recording file, which were related to the present case. However, despite securing new evidence relating to different charges, the prosecution did not obtain an additional search and seizure warrant and instead kept the evidence. The prosecution then used these materials to pursue a separate investigation into the crime of 'giving and receiving bribes' involving external evaluation committee members.



Regarding this, the appellate court sharply criticized the prosecution's actions as "illegal conduct that fundamentally violates the warrant requirement and due process principles stipulated by the Constitution and the Criminal Procedure Act," and completely excluded the documents and recorded files as admissible evidence. Under the so-called 'fruit of the poisonous tree' doctrine—that is, evidence derived from illegally obtained evidence is also inadmissible—the secondary evidence obtained on the basis of the illegal evidence, as well as the defendants' statements in court based on such evidence, could not be accepted as proof of guilt. The Supreme Court also found the appellate court’s ruling to be valid. The Supreme Court stated, "There is no error in the lower court’s application of the legal principles concerning illegally obtained evidence and the admissibility of secondary evidence," and dismissed the prosecution’s appeal, thereby confirming the acquittal verdict.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing