Court: "Belated Remorse Shown, Possibility of Rehabilitation Recognized"

The biological mother who was sentenced to life imprisonment in the first trial for habitually assaulting and neglecting her four-month-old infant son, resulting in his death, had her sentence reduced to 35 years in prison on appeal.

Yeosu Infant Abuse Murder Case. Screenshot from SBS 'Unanswered Questions' broadcast

Yeosu Infant Abuse Murder Case. Screenshot from SBS 'Unanswered Questions' broadcast

View original image

On August 25, the Gwangju High Court’s II Criminal Division (Presiding Judge Hwang Jin-hee) overturned the original life sentence for the mother, Ms. A (in her 30s), who had been indicted for child abuse resulting in death under the Act on Special Cases Concerning the Punishment of Child Abuse Crimes, and sentenced her to 35 years in prison.


For the biological father, Mr. B (age 36), who was indicted for child abandonment and neglect under the Child Welfare Act and had been sentenced to four years and six months in prison in the first trial, the court dismissed both the defendant’s and prosecutor’s appeals, upholding the original sentence.


The panel also ordered both individuals to complete 40 hours of a child abuse treatment program and prohibited them from employment at child-related institutions for 10 years.


Ms. A was brought to trial on charges of habitually abusing and killing her four-month-old son, “Haedeuni” (an alias), at her home in Yeosu, Jeollanam-do, between August 24 and October 21 of last year, with abuse occurring on 19 separate occasions.


She subjected the child to cruel acts such as grabbing his arms and lifting him into the air before throwing him onto the bed, or shaking his head and repeatedly slamming him against the bed.


On the day of the incident, October 22, she subjected the infant to indiscriminate violence for about 18 minutes because he had defecated, and left him unattended in a baby bathtub with the water running. The child, who sustained fractures in 23 areas of his body as well as internal abdominal and lung hemorrhages, died after 133 days of life.


Previously, the first trial court recognized Ms. A’s liability for murder on the grounds of indirect intent and sentenced her to life imprisonment, while sentencing Mr. B to four years and six months in prison for condoning and neglecting his wife’s abuse and intimidating a witness.


The appellate court strongly condemned Ms. A’s actions, calling them “inhumane and anti-social crimes in that she brutally abused the child she was supposed to protect and raise, ultimately depriving him of his life,” but determined that a life sentence was excessively harsh.


The court stated, “To permanently isolate the defendant from society, there must be clear objective circumstances,” adding, “It is difficult to see the crime as carefully premeditated, and it cannot be conclusively said that the defendant actively desired the child’s death.”


The court further explained, “Taking into consideration that the defendant has no previous criminal record, is showing belated remorse for the suffering of the victim, and that it cannot be completely ruled out that there is a possibility of rehabilitation through a long period of incarceration, the life sentence was disproportionate.”


After delivering the verdict, Judge Hwang Jin-hee, herself a mother of two, quoted from the book “Ruling Myself Until I Die,” and added, “The true purpose of punishment is rehabilitation and the restoration of the community.”



Regarding the biological father, Mr. B, the court remarked, “If he had intervened to prevent the abuse and separated the child, this tragic death could have been avoided,” and held that the sentence in the first trial was appropriate.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing