Analysis by Professor Ji Inyeop of Dongguk University on Behalf of the Association

Investment Declines as Risk Aversion Grows After Indictment

Calls for Clearer Legal Criteria

An empirical analysis has revealed that companies tend to reduce investments and significantly increase their cash holdings ratio, taking a more conservative management approach after disclosing indictments for embezzlement. It has been pointed out that the ambiguity in the current application of embezzlement laws and excessively harsh punishment regulations are greatly discouraging aggressive innovation and bold investment activities by businesses.


The Korea Economic Association (hereinafter referred to as the Association) announced on August 26 a report titled "The Effect of Embezzlement Charges on Corporate Risk Aversion," prepared by Professor Ji In-yeop of the Economics Department at Dongguk University.

Estimated increase in quarterly cash holding ratios following the announcement of embezzlement indictment. Korea Economic Association

Estimated increase in quarterly cash holding ratios following the announcement of embezzlement indictment. Korea Economic Association

View original image

According to the report, analysis of 119 listed companies that disclosed indictments for embezzlement between 2016 and 2026 showed that, from the quarter in which the indictment was disclosed and over the following seven quarters, the companies' cash holdings ratio statistically increased in a significant way.


In the quarter of disclosure itself (quarter 0), the cash holdings ratio rose only 1.7 percentage points compared to the previous quarter, but it gradually increased to 5.4 percentage points higher after seven quarters. This figure is equivalent to about 45% of the average cash holdings ratio (12.0%) for these companies during the analysis period.


The report explained that this significant mid- to long-term increase in the proportion of cash holdings, a representative safe asset, indicates that companies’ financial management strategies have shifted toward risk aversion following indictments for embezzlement. Considering that there was no notable increase in cash holdings prior to indictment, it can be interpreted that corporate sentiment became markedly more conservative after such events.


The current law regarding embezzlement has been criticized for imposing excessive burdens on corporate management due to vague requirements and standards—such as the ambiguous definition of "breach of duty"—that determine whether the crime has been committed. In fact, from 2015 to 2024, the acquittal rate in the first trial for embezzlement and breach of trust cases averaged 6.2%, more than double the overall criminal acquittal rate (3.0%).


The United States and the United Kingdom do not have separate embezzlement statutes. Instead, such issues are handled under fraud, misappropriation, or civil liability for damages. Similarly, continental law jurisdictions such as Germany and Japan widely apply the "business judgment rule," which exempts management from legal liability for losses as long as the decisions were made with the care of a good manager.


In contrast, South Korea not only criminalizes general and official embezzlement under its penal code, but also provides for harsher penalties through the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes. Under this act, if the financial gain involved exceeds 5 billion won, sentences of up to life imprisonment may be imposed.



Lee Sangho, head of the Economic Division at the Association, commented, "This research empirically confirms that the indictment for embezzlement alone, regardless of the final verdict, can stifle corporate innovation and investment activities." He emphasized, "In order to enhance business predictability and prevent rational decision-making from being discouraged, it is urgent to clarify the elements that constitute embezzlement and to codify the business judgment rule into law."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing