Split Opinions on Handheld Fan Use in Subways
6 Out of 10 in Japan Say "Refrain"

As Japan continues to experience extreme heatwaves with temperatures hovering around 40 degrees Celsius, a heated debate has erupted over the use of portable mini fans (handheld fans), now considered an essential item for the summer, on public transportation.


AI-generated image to assist in understanding the article.

AI-generated image to assist in understanding the article.

View original image


According to Yomiuri TV on the 25th, recent remarks posted on social media by broadcaster and columnist Brass Kobara have sparked this controversy.


He wrote, "Please turn off your handheld fans in the subway. The unpleasant wind containing the sweat from your face gets blown directly to me sitting next to you," adding, "Please use them only after making sure the wind isn’t directed at people on either side or behind you."


In an interview with Yomiuri TV, he further emphasized, "Blowing strong air at another person's face is very stressful. It's like blowing your breath on someone." He urged people to be considerate of those around them in public places and refrain from using the fans.


This post has since ignited ongoing debates online about the use of handheld fans in public transportation.


Opponents argue: "Body odor or perfume scents can be carried and spread by the fan," "In crowded spaces, it can be a nuisance to other passengers," and "It's important to maintain manners in public spaces."


On the 5th, when a severe heatwave warning approaching 40 degrees Celsius was issued across Seoul, Gyeonggi, and the western regions including Honam, commuters around Seoul Station were seen holding fans in their hands on their way to work. 2026.08.05 Photo by Dongju Yoon

On the 5th, when a severe heatwave warning approaching 40 degrees Celsius was issued across Seoul, Gyeonggi, and the western regions including Honam, commuters around Seoul Station were seen holding fans in their hands on their way to work. 2026.08.05 Photo by Dongju Yoon

View original image

On the other hand, proponents counter: "There's no other choice because it's so hot inside the subway. If someone collapses due to a heat-related illness, it'd cause even more trouble," "It's preferable to sweating and letting unpleasant odors spread," and "Some people actually seek out the breeze from others' fans."


In a survey conducted by Yomiuri TV targeting 400 men and women aged 15 and older, 57.5% of respondents said they were against using handheld fans in the subway. 42.5% were in favor.


There are also concerns about safety accidents. The Japan Consumer Affairs Agency has cautioned users, noting reports such as "hair got caught in a fan inside a packed subway car" and "after using a dropped fan, it emitted smoke and made a popping sound," and urged caution when using handheld fans.



Meanwhile, this controversy is also closely related to Japan’s 'meiwaku' culture, which emphasizes not causing inconvenience or harm to others. 'Meiwaku' refers to behavior that is seen as causing trouble or nuisance to others. In Japan, it's generally considered good manners to refrain from making phone calls in places like subways or buses, so as not to disturb fellow passengers.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing