Refused Order to Wear Uniform and Assaulted Another Inmate
Simultaneous Use of Metal Restraints, Head, and Ankle Protectors
Recommendation: "Use of Protective Equipment Must Be Documented on Video"

The National Human Rights Commission of Korea has called the prolonged simultaneous use of multiple protective devices on correctional facility inmates an excessive measure and has demanded steps to prevent future recurrence.


In the field inspection of correctional facilities last April, legal reporters wearing detention uniforms are experiencing the daily routine of inmates. Photo by Yonhap News.

In the field inspection of correctional facilities last April, legal reporters wearing detention uniforms are experiencing the daily routine of inmates. Photo by Yonhap News.

View original image

On August 25, the Human Rights Commission announced that it had recommended job training at a detention center where three types of protective equipment were used on an inmate for more than nine hours. The Commission advised the warden to provide training for staff members, emphasizing the need to carefully assess the necessity and appropriateness of protective equipment before use, and to prevent the application of excessive physical force. It also recommended that the use of protective equipment must be documented with video equipment such as body cameras.


The complainant claimed that being forced to wear multiple protective devices for disobeying a correctional officer’s orders was unjust. The detention center responded that the complainant had exercised in the facility after removing their uniform and had refused the order to wear the standard-issue clothing. Additionally, the detainee was said to have struck another inmate on the thigh and then verbally abused an officer who tried to intervene, which the facility cited as the reason for the need to use protective equipment.


According to the Protective Equipment Review Board’s records, the complainant was fitted with metal restraints at 9:20 a.m. Five minutes later, from 9:25 a.m. to 8:45 p.m., the individual was simultaneously wearing metal restraints, a head protector, and ankle restraints. Apart from short breaks for meals and bathroom use, the three types of protective equipment were worn for a total of nine hours and twenty-five minutes.


The Commission acknowledged that there was a need for the use of protective equipment to some extent at the time. However, it found that a sufficiently specific and individualized necessity for using all three types of equipment simultaneously and for such a long duration was not established. The Commission clarified that the necessity for protective equipment and the appropriateness of using several types of equipment for prolonged periods are separate matters.


In particular, the absence of body camera footage during the use of protective equipment was identified as problematic. CCTV footage only confirmed that after leaving the living quarters barefoot, the complainant was moved to the detention team office by several officers, who were seen pushing the detainee’s head down or restraining them on the floor. However, with no footage specifically documenting the equipment’s application, it was difficult to objectively verify the actual use of physical force or assess whether the protective devices were used appropriately.



The Commission stressed that the necessity and appropriateness of protective equipment must be evaluated before use in correctional facilities, and its application should be minimized and carried out in stages, with the entire process documented and managed. A Commission representative stated, "These steps are necessary to protect the freedom and dignity of inmates while also safeguarding correctional officers who have lawfully performed their duties."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing