Seoul National University Bundang Hospital Team Led by Kiwoong Kim and Jiwon Han
High-Risk Elderly Drivers Can Be Identified with Years of Education and Trail Making Test

On August 24, Seoul National University Bundang Hospital announced that a research team led by Professors Kiwoong Kim and Jiwon Han of the Department of Psychiatry has presented a method to identify high-risk elderly drivers, even among those with no record of traffic law violations or accidents. The approach involves using a brief 'Trail Making Test'—which takes about two minutes—along with the driver’s years of education to screen for high-risk individuals who require a more thorough evaluation of driving ability.


Accidents involving elderly drivers have a higher fatality rate compared to other age groups, making it crucial to identify drivers at greater risk. However, traditional cognitive function tests alone are limited in their ability to predict actual accident risk.


The research team analyzed the responses of 1,673 male drivers aged 60 and over who participated in the Korean Longitudinal Study on Cognitive Aging and Dementia (KLOSCAD), comparing their self-reported driving risk survey results with police traffic accident records over the subsequent two years. The survey investigated the number of traffic law violations and accidents, as well as the number of accidents for which the driver was at fault over the previous three years. Both the drivers and their family members completed the surveys, and their responses were compared.

(From left) Kiwoong Kim, Professor Han Jiwon, Department of Psychiatry, Bundang Seoul National University Hospital. Bundang Seoul National University Hospital

(From left) Kiwoong Kim, Professor Han Jiwon, Department of Psychiatry, Bundang Seoul National University Hospital. Bundang Seoul National University Hospital

View original image

During the two-year follow-up, 290 out of 1,673 participants (17.3%) were confirmed to have been involved in an at-fault traffic accident resulting in injury. Drivers who reported more traffic law violations and accident experiences on the survey faced a higher future accident risk. For each one-point increase in the related score, the accident risk rose by 1.28 times.


However, among those 290 drivers involved in accidents, 111 (38.3%) had responded that they had no experience of traffic law violations or accidents at the time of the survey. This group, referred to as the 'silent high-risk group,' included both drivers and family members who failed to recognize danger signals. Among all participants' families, 94.3% stated that they had never observed any violations or accidents, and family members of those in the silent high-risk group provided similar answers, demonstrating that family surveys alone make it difficult to identify at-risk drivers in advance.


The research team further analyzed 876 drivers who reported no record of violations or accidents, considering variables such as age, years of education, and cognitive test results. The study found that drivers with fewer years of education and longer Trail Making Test completion times were at higher risk of accidents.


Accident rates were 20.9% for drivers who had nine years or less of education and took at least 180 seconds to complete the Trail Making Test—more than double the 9.1% rate of those who did not meet both criteria. This difference remained even after adjusting for factors such as age.


The Trail Making Test is a cognitive function test that measures the ability to shift attention and make rapid judgments by alternating between connecting numbers and letters. The research team interpreted a shorter education period as an indicator of a reduced ability to recognize and judge one’s own functional decline, while longer test completion times reflected slower processing and diminished executive function for handling complex driving situations.


The team clarified that the criteria are not meant to restrict driving, but rather to prioritize individuals who need a more detailed assessment of their driving skills. They also emphasized that years of education were used not as an indicator of educational attainment, but as a gauge for the capacity to recognize changes in one’s own abilities.



Professor Kim stated, "A significant number of drivers involved in accidents belonged to the silent high-risk group, where neither they nor their families recognized the danger. It is not safe to assume someone is low-risk solely because they have no record of violations or accidents." Professor Han added, "With a simple check involving years of education and a two-minute Trail Making Test, high-risk individuals can be identified early in clinics or when renewing a driver’s license, aiding prompt referral for detailed driving assessments. We plan to expand this research to include female drivers and various driving environments." The research findings were recently published in the international journal 'Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.'


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing