Court: “Partial Settlement Does Not Waive Right to Contract Deposit”
Construction Company's Claim of "No Obligation to Pay Contract Deposit" Dismissed

Yongin Special City in Gyeonggi Province (Mayor Lee Sangil) has won its appeal in a lawsuit against a construction company that abandoned a road expansion and paving project, resulting in the city collecting a contract deposit of over 426 million won as municipal revenue.

Aerial view of Yongin Special City Hall. Provided by Yongin City

Aerial view of Yongin Special City Hall. Provided by Yongin City

View original image

In December 2023, Yongin City signed a contract with Construction Company A for a road expansion and paving project with a total project cost of more than 8.5 billion won. However, approximately four months after commencement, on April 3, 2024, Company A submitted a statement of abandonment for the project. The city subsequently terminated the contract on April 12, 2024, citing breach of contract by the company.


Yongin City then claimed the contract deposit of 426 million won from a mutual aid association in accordance with local contract law. This law stipulates that if a contractor fails to fulfill their contractual obligations, the contract deposit is forfeited to the local government.


Company A filed a lawsuit, arguing that by drawing up a partial settlement agreement, all creditor and debtor relationships were resolved, and that Yongin City had failed to prove any actual losses incurred. Thus, they claimed there was no obligation for them to pay the contract deposit.


The court of first instance accepted the company’s argument. However, the 2nd Civil Division of the Suwon High Court, which handled the appeal, overturned the decision and ruled in favor of Yongin City.


The court stated, "It is clear that the contract was terminated due to the construction company's abandonment of the project," and found that "the non-litigation clause in the subsequent settlement agreement simply indicates that the parties will not dispute the return of the advance payment and the settlement amount. It does not mean that Yongin City waived its right to the contract deposit."


With the ruling finalized, Yongin City processed the contract deposit of 426 million won as city revenue. This verdict is being recognized as a case affirming the local government's right to retain contract deposits in the event of termination and partial settlement of public contracts.


An official from Yongin City stated, "When a construction project is suspended due to a contractor's fault, public works are delayed and citizens' inconvenience increases. Through rigorous legal action, we will establish order in public contracting and prevent financial loss to the city."



The official continued, "Suspension of construction due to a contractor's breach constitutes a serious violation of contract, resulting in delays to public works and increased inconvenience for citizens. We will strictly adhere to the principles and laws governing public contracts, enforce robust legal action to foster a sound public contracting environment, and prevent financial loss to the city."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing