“It Is Difficult to Recognize Supplier Requests as Voluntary Based Solely on the Removal Request Form”

The Supreme Court has finalized a penalty of 1.027 billion won imposed on GS Retail for unfairly returning products to suppliers and passing on promotional event expenses to them.

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

According to the legal community on August 23, the third division of the Supreme Court, presided over by Justice Roe Kyungphil, recently upheld a lower court ruling dismissing GS Retail's suit against the Fair Trade Commission seeking to annul corrective orders and penalties.


Previously, the Fair Trade Commission had issued a corrective order, a notification order, and an order to pay a penalty of 1.027 billion won. The commission found that from April 2017 to October 2019, GS Retail violated Article 10, Paragraph 1 of the Large-scale Retail Business Act by returning a significant number of products to suppliers only after receiving a request for removal, rather than properly documenting the returns process. Furthermore, from January 2015 to November 2018, the company was found to have violated Article 11, Paragraphs 1 and 2 of the same law by carrying out promotional events, such as offering gifts, and shifting the associated costs to suppliers without any prior written agreement on cost sharing. Additionally, from January 2018 to June 2020, GS Retail was judged to have violated Article 12, Paragraph 1 by allowing professional broadcasters and entertainers hired by suppliers to work as broadcast guests and models without a written agreement on dispatch conditions.


The key points of contention were whether the request forms or official documents obtained by GS Retail from suppliers constituted objective supporting evidence for the legitimacy of the returns. It was also disputed whether guests employed by suppliers who appeared on GS Home Shopping broadcasts qualified as employees under the law, and whether such broadcast appearances could be considered as labor performed by dispatched employees. Furthermore, there was debate over whether the calculation of the penalty exceeded the Fair Trade Commission's discretionary authority.


The appellate court ruled against GS Retail. It found that merely requesting product returns based on a removal request form was insufficient to recognize the voluntary nature of the suppliers' requests for return. Of the 562 employees mentioned by the Fair Trade Commission as working for the suppliers, it determined that 556 were recognized as having worked at the business location in violation of Article 12 of the Large-scale Retail Business Act.



The court also found no illegality in the calculation of the penalty. It noted that the amount involved in the violation of the product return prohibition was considerable, at around 1.8 billion won, and that a large-scale retailer like GS Retail using its superior transactional position to impose undue disadvantages would risk normalizing abnormal business practices and significantly undermine fair trade.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing