[Beopssosigae] The Farce of "Supreme Court Justice Recommendation by Letter"... The Stark Collapse of the Separation of Powers View original image

The country is in turmoil over the unprecedented situation of a "Supreme Court Justice Recommendation by Letter." While there has always been a tug-of-war between the right of recommendation (the judiciary) and the right of appointment (the executive branch), there has never been such a breakdown in which the usual courtesies and customs were omitted and the transfer of personnel authority occurred through a single document.


The Supreme Court Chief Justice’s right of recommendation is not a mere suggestion. It is a powerful constitutional mechanism designed to prevent the president, as the highest elected authority, from dominating the judiciary. For that reason, the recommendation process has always been tense, involving delicate behind-the-scenes negotiations between both parties. Former Supreme Court Chief Justice Lee Yong-hoon once remarked, "If it weren't for the Supreme Court Justice nomination, serving as the Chief Justice would be quite manageable."


The most intense battle of wits took place in August 2009. At the time, Chief Justice Lee and President Lee Myung-bak fiercely competed over the selection of a new Supreme Court Justice. Having spent 2 years and 5 months under President Roh Moo-hyun who appointed him, Chief Justice Lee had to spend another 3 years and 7 months after the change in administration with President Lee. The Supreme Court held its ground with concerns that judicial independence would be compromised if a particular candidate, strongly backed by the Blue House, was appointed. In response, Chief Justice Lee took a bold step by recommending three candidates at once and passed the ball back to the Blue House. Both sides managed to avoid a complete breakdown and found common ground. Even when there were disagreements, at the very least, the formal custom of the Chief Justice visiting the Blue House for a face-to-face recommendation and mutual respect was maintained. This was a matter of decorum between state institutions and an implicit rule supporting the separation of powers.


So, after 17 years, what is the current landscape between the judiciary and the executive branch? Is it still possible to maintain implicit rules and mutual respect? The beginning of this rift came last year, when the impeachment of Supreme Court Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae was openly discussed following the Supreme Court’s overturning of a presidential case with a guilty verdict. It was a painful crack in the last line between the two key constitutional institutions. The conduct of the legislature was even more striking. For the first time in constitutional history, the head of the Supreme Court—a pillar of the separation of powers—was summoned to the National Assembly’s Legislation and Judiciary Committee and berated. Placards reading "Heedaeyoshi" even appeared. Impeachment was brought up against individual judges whenever rulings were not to lawmakers' liking. At the August 17 Democratic Party convention, the impeachment of Chief Justice Cho was used as a tool for candidates to prove their hard-line credentials. The ruling bloc went even further, unilaterally pushing through the so-called "three major judicial reform bills," which focused on creating the crime of judicial distortion, increasing the number of Supreme Court justices, and introducing a trial appeal system. In such a harsh environment, with political power leading the way in tightening and controlling the judiciary, there was never a place for customs based on mutual respect to survive.


In truth, the trigger behind the current deadlock over the appointments was the nomination issue of High Court Judge Kim Min-ki, whom the Blue House wanted. The Supreme Court opposed the nomination, expressing concerns about potential conflicts of interest and judicial fairness, since Judge Kim's spouse is a sitting Constitutional Court Justice. If past rules had been followed, this sharp disagreement likely would have been resolved through healthy deliberation among constitutional institutions.



Constitutional customs are a sophisticated agreement that functions only on the foundation of mutual respect and trust among constitutional institutions. In a situation where the political sphere is leading the dismantling of decades of long-standing limits that protected judicial independence, it is inconsistent to demand procedural virtue only from the Chief Justice. On the surface, this may seem like a personnel negotiation failure, but fundamentally, it exposes the deepening conflict and discord between the legislative/executive branches and the judiciary. Ultimately, this recommendation-by-letter episode is the product of an era where mutual respect among constitutional institutions has completely evaporated. It is time for South Korea to seriously reflect on how its separation of powers has become so thoroughly devastated.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing