“There Is Also an Argument That Descendants Should Not Be Held Responsible”

Amid controversy surrounding actor Ha Young due to her great-grandfather's pro-Japanese activities, a Japanese media outlet has highlighted the debate over pro-Japanese collaborators in Korea.


On August 20, Japanese online media Abema Times addressed the recent controversy in Korea regarding Ha Young's great-grandfather, An Sang-ho (1872~1927), and suspicions of his pro-Japanese actions. An Sang-ho is known to have been listed as a member of the council of the pro-Japanese organization “Daijeong Chinmokhoe,” which was formed in 1916, and faces suspicions of pro-Japanese activities.


The outlet reported that favorability toward Japan among South Koreans reached 54.3%, the highest level since 2013 when such surveys began. It also noted that while cultural and entertainment exchanges between Korea and Japan are increasingly active, anti-Japanese sentiment surfaces whenever historical issues arise, drawing attention to the context behind these responses.


Actor Ha Young is talking about her family background on the variety show "Problem Children of the Rooftop Room," which aired on KBS 2TV on the 7th. Photo by KBS

Actor Ha Young is talking about her family background on the variety show "Problem Children of the Rooftop Room," which aired on KBS 2TV on the 7th. Photo by KBS

View original image

Kim Kyungjoo, professor at Tokai University in Japan, commented on the controversy regarding Ha Young's great-grandfather, saying, "It is indeed a fact that her great-grandfather engaged in several ‘pro-Japanese acts.’" However, he explained, "there is an argument that responsibility for ‘pro-Japanese acts’ should be limited strictly to the individual concerned and that it is wrong to hold the family or descendants accountable."


Professor Kim pointed to the fact that pro-Japanese figures accumulated wealth while cooperating with the Japanese government as a background for the criticism directed at Ha Young. He stated, "Pro-Japanese individuals at the time received land or accumulated property through cooperation with the Japanese government. Ha Young boasted, 'My family is affluent and reputable,' but the issue is whether that wealth stemmed from pro-Japanese activities."


He also provided an analysis that perceptions of Japan among the young generation in Korea are changing compared to the past. Professor Kim argued, "Young people today like Japan, but they also freely consider the possibility that there may be problems with Japan’s historical awareness, according to each case. It has become difficult for politics to instigate anti-Japan sentiment like it once did."



Nonetheless, he said conflict factors between Korea and Japan, such as issues of historical awareness or the Dokdo issue, could continue to arise repeatedly in the future. Professor Kim remarked, "As time goes by, there is an increasing number of people who are able to view such issues more objectively." He added, "It would be good if both sides could gradually learn how to view and understand these issues."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing