The Conspiracy Theory Sparked by History Influencer Chao Yu

"Complete Nonsense... A Dynasty with Overwhelming Historical Evidence"

Bizarre claims that the Tang Dynasty never existed have been spreading online in China, reportedly causing headaches for both the Chinese government and state-run media.

Reenacting the envoy's entrance ceremony of the Tang Dynasty. Photo by The Asia Business Daily Database

Reenacting the envoy's entrance ceremony of the Tang Dynasty. Photo by The Asia Business Daily Database

View original image

According to reports from CNN and major Chinese outlets such as the People’s Daily on August 19, the controversy was sparked back in May when Chao Yu, an influencer who creates historical content, posted a video claiming—with reference to astrological data—that the Tang Dynasty (618–907 AD) never actually existed and that the Song Dynasty was founded much earlier than widely believed.


Chinese netizens have linked this argument to a theory from German author Heribert Illig, which has already been disproven in international historical and astronomical circles. Illig argued that European history from 614 to 911 AD was fabricated by later generations.


Since then, the hashtag “The Tang Dynasty Doesn’t Exist” has gone viral on Chinese social media platform Weibo, racking up tens of millions of views in a very short time.


In some extreme cases, people have even called the tourism office in Xi’an—the ancient capital of the Tang Dynasty—to demand an end to tourism based on what they claim is “fake history.”


Some analysts suggest this conspiracy theory is part of an extreme nationalist push to discredit the Tang Dynasty because it was not founded by Han Chinese, but the academic community uniformly rejects the claims as utterly meritless.


William Kirby, Professor of China Studies at Harvard University, dismissed the theory outright, describing it as “fundamentally irrational” and “complete nonsense.” He emphasized, “The Tang was a vast empire spanning the interiors of Asia, and its historical evidence is extraordinarily clear. The Tang Dynasty was more than just a Chinese dynasty.”


As the controversy grew, Chinese authorities—who exercise tight control over historical interpretation under President Xi Jinping—moved quickly to address the situation. The People’s Daily, the official newspaper of the Communist Party, published an editorial strongly condemning the claim as “utterly absurd” and warned that if young people began doubting their nation’s history, China’s path to modernization could lose a profound historical perspective.


The Paper, a government-run media outlet in Shanghai, also denounced the phenomenon as “historical nihilism” in opposition to the Party’s official narrative, and vowed a firm response.



Meanwhile, Chao Yu’s account was blocked and all related videos were removed in mid-August.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing