Policies Lacking Infrastructure and Structural Change
Consider "Real Lives," Not Just Lives to Endure
Start With a Clear Understanding of Reality

[Young]Do You Really Want to Send Young People to the Provinces? View original image

The policies introduced by the government to revitalize dying provinces are certainly welcome. However, the current depopulated regions are structured in a way that leaves young people with no choice but to leave. The policies, too, merely try to persuade young people to return without addressing the reasons why they left in the first place. In a sense, it is no surprise these policies have failed.


I attended school in Yeongdeok, North Gyeongsang Province. The decision to move to Seoul to continue my studies was one I had no other choice but to make. In Yeongdeok, there are neither universities to aspire to, nor suitable jobs. According to recent resident registration population statistics from the Ministry of the Interior and Safety, Yeongdeok's population stood at 32,356. The number of those in their 60s is about seven times the number of those in their 20s. Just walking around the streets of Yeongdeok quickly reveals the reality. It’s difficult to find people in their twenties on the street.


Young people are always at the center of government policy. There is an underlying assumption that provinces will be revived if only the young people concentrated in the metropolitan area can be sent back to the provinces. This idea doesn’t resonate with me. Policies are announced to attract young people to the regions, but I can’t shake the feeling that this is a textbook example of desk-bound bureaucracy.


For instance, measures to encourage companies to build semiconductor factories in the Honam area, and the so-called “megaprojects” related to them, seem entirely aimed at securing large numbers of local jobs. The relocation of government ministries and public enterprises to provincial areas is along the same lines. The same goes for policies concerning marriage and education—there is talk of a plan to create “ten universities like Seoul National University.”


There are many different policies, but all are rife with shortcomings. Most are the sorts of measures that take a long time to materialize. It’s unclear and uncertain when, if ever, they will touch our lives. As young people, we cannot stake our immediate futures on such policies. Moving to a province is a life-changing decision for us. It is a complex problem, with multiple overlapping factors. Where you live determines your job, your family, your interpersonal relationships, and can completely shape the course of your career. Seoul is an environment that offers a range of options, while the provinces are not. Thus, moving to the provinces represents a loss of options. Young people cannot easily leave Seoul.


Despite all this, the thinking in political circles is far too simplistic. There is not even a sense of consideration or respect. I wish they would reflect on why their youth-oriented policies are subject to criticism from young people in the first place. Recently, the government announced plans to more than double the financial support given to youth who find employment in the provinces. This suggests an attempt to sway young people with money, which makes me uncomfortable. It also makes it feel like young people are being treated not as active participants in policy, but as mere recipients of state largesse.


The recent controversy surrounding Democratic Party lawmaker Hwang Hee’s “bus house” proposal is another example. Assemblyman Hwang suggested converting decommissioned buses into residential spaces for young people, but faced backlash and eventually apologized. The very idea of using an old bus as a dwelling implies that youth housing is not about providing a life, but about offering makeshift solutions—a hardship to be endured rather than a life to be lived.


The policies introduced by the government to encourage youth migration to the provinces are full of incomplete measures. Long-term strategies that involve transforming social structures, such as infrastructure improvements, are necessary. Discussions that delve into the true intentions of the youth must also accompany these efforts. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

The policies introduced by the government to encourage youth migration to the provinces are full of incomplete measures. Long-term strategies that involve transforming social structures, such as infrastructure improvements, are necessary. Discussions that delve into the true intentions of the youth must also accompany these efforts. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

Though these policies claim to support young people, do they truly consider what young people feel, or even care enough to try? Effective policies must begin with a clear understanding of young people’s real circumstances. The reasons for leaving their hometowns for Seoul will vary person to person. It may be difficult to account for each and every situation, but that is precisely why we must strive to identify common denominators. As always, the most important factor is infrastructure. Hospitals and schools in the smaller provincial cities continue to disappear or leave these areas.


If there were adequate opportunities and choices no matter where one lived, I would also readily consider relocating. Instead of clinging to simplistic notions—such as what incentives might make young people move to the provinces—it would be better to prioritize policies that invest in expanding infrastructure and making structural changes, even if such a process takes time. The immediate results may be small, but it is the only truly fundamental solution.


Above all else, what matters most is whether policymakers show meticulous attention to and genuine understanding of young people’s true feelings and real situations during the process of policy development. Unless this happens, any youth policy put forward by the political establishment will be doomed to fail—no matter the incentives on offer.


Kim Nayoung, Department of Communication and Media, Ewha Womans University



The Asia Business Daily welcomes contributions from young writers with diverse ideas and experiences. Columns will be published in the [young域] section and widely distributed. If you would like to contribute, please send your article—around 2,000 characters in length—alongside a brief self-introduction to column@asiae.co.kr. We will inform you after reviewing your submission. Selected columns will be published both in print and online, and a nominal fee will be paid.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing