Korea Patient Organization Federation and Assemblywoman Choi Boyun Hold National Assembly Forum

Protection Needed for Medical Staff Accepting Patients at the Request of Emergency Control Centers

Compensation and Incentives for Medical Institutions Must Also Be Addressed

In order to resolve the so-called "emergency room cycling" phenomenon, where emergency patients are forced to move from one medical institution to another because they cannot find a hospital for treatment, a proposal has been made to reasonably alleviate the criminal liability imposed on medical personnel and, at the same time, to establish a state-led public compensation system for affected patients and their families.


At the discussion forum titled 'Improvement of Criminal Responsibility in Emergency Medical Care and Establishment of Compensation System for Victims to Resolve Emergency Room Cycling,' held at the National Assembly Members' Office Building in Yeouido, Seoul on the 19th, participants are speaking. Korean Patient Organization Alliance

At the discussion forum titled 'Improvement of Criminal Responsibility in Emergency Medical Care and Establishment of Compensation System for Victims to Resolve Emergency Room Cycling,' held at the National Assembly Members' Office Building in Yeouido, Seoul on the 19th, participants are speaking. Korean Patient Organization Alliance

View original image

The Korea Patient Organization Federation and Assemblywoman Choi Boyun of the People Power Party held a forum on August 19th at the National Assembly Members' Office Building titled "Measures to Improve Criminal Liability in Emergency Medical Care and Establish Compensation Systems for Victims to Resolve Emergency Room Cycling," where they discussed the judicial risks that occur during the admission process of emergency patients and options for relief for the injured.


Currently, the Emergency Medical Service Act allows for the sentence to be reduced or exempted in cases where emergency medical workers perform urgent medical treatment to prevent danger to life or serious harm, the action was unavoidable, and there was no gross negligence. However, because the reduction or exemption is left to the discretion of the court, rather than being a "mandatory exemption," medical staff still face significant burdens with police investigations, prosecution, and trials.


An Gijong, president of the Korea Patient Organization Federation and the day's presenter, argued that there should be specific legal protections for medical personnel who accept and treat critically ill emergency patients at the request of regional emergency medical control centers or 119 emergency dispatch control centers, even when they would not normally have admitted such cases. Specifically, he suggested a system where, even if a hospital has legitimate grounds for not being able to accept a patient, if the hospital accepts a patient at the request of the public transfer system and the medical staff acted without intent or gross negligence, their criminal liability for occupational negligence resulting in injury or death should be mandatorily exempted. At the same time, he proposed the establishment of a public compensation system, funded by the Emergency Medical Fund, to provide compensation to patients and their families when harm does occur during this process.


Support measures for medical institutions were also proposed. An explained, "For medical institutions that accept additional critically ill emergency patients, extra reimbursements under the National Health Insurance and support from the Emergency Medical Fund should be provided, and the actual patient acceptance record and public contributions should be reflected in the evaluations of emergency medical institutions and in the designation or re-designation of top-tier general hospitals."


Professor Park Sungmin of Seoul National University Graduate School of Public Health pointed out, "There is a need to clearly define in the law the standards for determining negligence that reflect the particular nature of emergency medical care." He emphasized it is important to incorporate into the law the Supreme Court's precedents that evaluation of negligence should take into account the circumstances and conditions at the time of treatment, as well as the urgency and uncertainty characteristic of emergency care, so as to reduce the perception among medical professionals that "if the patient's outcome is poor, they will automatically be held criminally liable."


Professor Park also stated, "When a hospital provides treatment to a patient at the request of an emergency medical situation room despite difficult circumstances, such hospitals should receive more focused subsidies and support through evaluations of emergency medical institutions." He added, "Compensation for affected patients should not be limited only to cases of death or severe damage, but should be more widely considered using the Emergency Medical Fund."


On the other hand, there were opinions that simply expanding exemptions from criminal liability for medical staff would not solve the problem of emergency room cycling. Professor Jung Kyungwon, trauma surgery professor at Ajou University Hospital, emphasized, "Depending on the severity and type of the patient's illness, it is necessary to designate a primary hospital in advance, and if the primary hospital cannot accept the patient, a backup and bypass system that works immediately should be in place, as well as an integrated information system linking patient triage and final treatment." He stressed that rather than merely matching patients with available hospitals, a system where "the patient's destination is assured from the start" is needed.


Legal experts also voiced caution about expanding criminal liability exemptions. Park Hokyun, managing attorney at Hippocrates Law Firm, agreed on the need to clarify legitimate grounds for refusing to accept emergency patients and to establish a control tower for designating transfer hospitals, but stated, "Given the current legal system and related considerations, broad exemptions from civil and criminal liability should be approached with caution."


Lee Junggyu, Director of Public Health Policy at the Ministry of Health and Welfare, explained, "Emergency room cycling is a complex issue not only involving criminal liability, but also factors such as the capabilities of emergency rooms and their related departments, shortages of medical personnel and hospital beds, regional disparities in medical infrastructure, and lack of information sharing among institutions." The government is currently undertaking pilot projects to share information held by each entity and coordinate which hospitals receive patients at a regional level. Moving forward, the evaluation of emergency medical institutions is planned to shift its focus from process-oriented factors such as facilities and beds to whether the institution actually admits and provides final treatments, such as emergency surgeries, to critical emergency patients.


Parents who had lost children during emergency medical care also attended the forum. A mother pregnant with twins at 28 weeks went to seven hospitals in the Daegu area before being transferred to a top-tier general hospital in Bundang, about four hours away, for an emergency C-section. Tragically, one baby died and the other suffered brain damage. In Goyang City, Gyeonggi Province, a 19-month-old child died while being transferred from a hospital that lacked pediatric endoscopy equipment to another facility after their condition worsened during transit.



These parents requested, "The government and the National Assembly should implement effective measures to prevent such tragedies from happening again to other children like ours."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing