Hospital Fire Caused by Unregistered Heating Cable Installation
Supreme Court Overturns Not-Guilty Verdict and Remands Case

The Supreme Court has ruled that even if the specific ignition process of a fire cannot be proven with direct evidence, it is possible to recognize a causal link between professional negligence and the fire by comprehensively considering multiple circumstantial facts.

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

According to legal sources on the 20th, the Third Division of the Supreme Court (presiding Justice Lee Heung-gu) recently overturned the not-guilty verdict handed down to Construction Company CEO A and Hospital Facilities Manager B, who were indicted on charges including professional negligence resulting in fire, and remanded the case to the Cheongju District Court.


Unregistered contractor A was commissioned in March 2022 by Hospital Facilities Manager B to install heating wires in the ceiling of a hospital parking lot in Cheongju, Chungcheongbuk-do, in order to prevent water pipes from freezing. However, A did not use pre-certified finished products, instead purchasing self-regulating heating cables, temperature sensors, and power supply wires separately and assembling an anti-freezing device on his own. The ends of the self-regulating wire were wrapped only with vinyl insulation tape.


After the work was completed, the circuit breaker on the outlet connected to the heating wire continued to trip. B reset the breaker and once again connected the heating wire to the outlet; about five minutes later, a fire broke out in the parking lot ceiling. The fire spread to parts of both the new and old hospital buildings as well as an adjacent motel, burning approximately 2,500 square meters across the three buildings. The damages were assessed at approximately 2,028,000,000 won.


A fire investigation found evidence of a short circuit at the end of the self-regulating heating cable installed by A. No other electrical or mechanical factors were found that could have caused the fire.


The main issue was whether, even without clarification of the specific cause and process of the short circuit that led to the fire, A’s act of assembling and installing an uncertified electrical device as an unregistered contractor and B’s failure as a facilities manager to verify the contractor’s qualifications and work safety could be recognized as professional negligence.


The court of first instance found both individuals guilty of professional negligence resulting in fire. The appellate court, however, overturned the verdict and found both not guilty. The appellate court determined that it could not be definitively stated that a short circuit would not have occurred if A had used pre-certified products and that there was no proof that A had failed to notify B about the malfunctioning outlet. While the appellate court recognized that B was negligent in commissioning the work to unregistered contractor A, it held that since it could not be concluded that the fire was caused by A’s negligence, there was also no causal relationship between B’s negligence and the fire.



The Supreme Court did not accept this reasoning. The Supreme Court stated that in cases of professional negligence resulting in fire, it is not necessary for the specific ignition process to be clearly proven with direct evidence when determining negligence and causality. The Court held that the causal relationship between professional negligence and fire can be inferred by comprehensively considering legally admitted evidence and multiple circumstantial facts.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing