Plenary Session of the Legislation and Judiciary Committee on August 19

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

On August 19, Noh Kyung-pil, Director of the National Court Administration, commented on the calls for impeachment against Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae, stating, "I have doubts as to whether the reasons presented meet the requirements." Regarding the controversy over the written nomination of Supreme Court justices, he added, "I do not think Chief Justice Cho politicized the judiciary."


Director Noh made these remarks during a plenary session of the National Assembly’s Legislation and Judiciary Committee in response to questions from Park Ji-won, a lawmaker from the Democratic Party of Korea. When Assemblyman Park asked, in reference to Chief Justice Cho’s written nomination, whether the move was meant to take a stand against the President, Director Noh responded, "It was not intended as a confrontation." When Park referred to Chief Justice Cho as "an insurrectionary force," Noh countered, "I do not agree with that."


Director Noh reiterated, concerning Assemblyman Park's claim that Chief Justice Cho ought to be impeached, "I have doubts as to whether the stated grounds are sufficient." In response to Democratic Party lawmaker Kim Gipyo's question about whether there had ever been a case in the past where nominations were announced in writing without prior consensus, Noh said, "This time, we consulted up to the last minute. While there was consultation, there was no consensus."


Director Noh also explained that although he called the candidates recommended as successors to former Supreme Court Justice Noh Tae-ak by the Supreme Court Justice Nominating Committee in January, "I did not tell them to step down." He elaborated, "There was an idea among the various options that, for the four previously nominated as candidates, we could consider starting a new nomination process. For this idea to move forward, all four of the nominated candidates would have had to agree."


Regarding Assemblyman Kim’s question about whether Chief Justice Cho instructed him to act in this way, Director Noh answered, "He did not instruct me to do so."


Meanwhile, on the previous day (August 18), Chief Justice Cho nominated Son Bong-gi, Senior Judge at the Daegu District Court (age 61, 22nd class), and Kim Sung-soo, Senior Judge at the Seoul High Court (age 58, 24th class), to President Lee Jae-myung as new Supreme Court justice candidates.


However, it is reported that Chief Justice Cho did not consult with the Office of the President in advance regarding the nomination of Judge Son as the successor to former Supreme Court Justice Noh Tae-ak. Judge Kim was nominated to replace Supreme Court Justice Lee Heung-gu (age 63, 22nd class). Since the convention of prior consultation followed by an in-person nomination has been broken, with the nomination this time made in writing, there are concerns that the appointment process may experience inevitable complications.



Chief Justice Cho declined to answer related questions from the press on both the previous day and this day.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing