[The View] The New Helplessness Created by the Ease of AI
There is a typical scene that has become common on university campuses these days. When students receive an assignment and open their laptops, they launch a generative AI program even before opening a word processor or internet browser. Before thinking for themselves about what to write, they first ask AI what should be written. More and more students are unable to endure that brief moment required to craft the very first sentence from a blank page. The real change facing universities in the AI era is not simply that students are using AI, but rather that an increasing number find it difficult to even start without AI.
There is a concept in psychology known as learned helplessness. It refers to a phenomenon where people give up trying altogether after repeated experiences of failure. Interestingly, the helplessness created by AI is coming from the exact opposite direction. Rather than repeated failure, it is the excessive ease of success that induces helplessness in people. When starting something becomes too easy, people lose the ability to initiate on their own.
If all that was disappearing were the ability to draft an outline, it might not amount to a major problem. However, it is precisely that moment of hesitation before a blank page where thinking is generated. In deciding what to write, we are compelled to determine for ourselves what we actually know, what we do not know, and from which angle to approach the issue. When we skip this decision-making process, we may still produce a result, but our capacity for thought does not develop.
In a study by MIT Media Lab, 54 college students in the Boston area were divided into three groups and asked to repeatedly write SAT-style essays over four months. One group used ChatGPT only, another group used only Google Search, and a third group worked without any tools. As their brain activity was continuously monitored with EEG equipment, it was found that the ChatGPT group exhibited the lowest brain connectivity, which decreased further over time. The most surprising finding was that these students could not accurately quote sentences from the essays they just wrote. While almost everyone in the group who wrote without assistance could quote exactly, virtually no one in the ChatGPT group could do so. The essays they wrote, in effect, were not truly their own.
Concerns that technology diminishes human abilities are nothing new. Calculators have replaced mental arithmetic, GPS has stood in for our sense of direction, and autocomplete has substituted for spelling. However, previous technologies replaced a single, specific ability. AI is different. AI takes over the very moment when thinking begins. Rather than substituting for a narrow skill, it replaces the starting point for all cognitive activity. The scope of what is being replaced is entirely different.
The impact of this change on the labor market is already emerging. If everyone begins with AI, then everyone starts from a similar place. Differences arise later, in editing and judgment. That is why the market now favors those who can skillfully refine drafts produced by AI. Yet, in the longer term, the truly rare ability lies elsewhere. It will become uncommon to find people who can originate the first sentence that no one else has written, ask the first question that no one else has posed, or choose the first direction that no one else has taught. We are entering an era with many editors and few authors.
The implication for education is clear. What universities must protect going forward is not a set of rules prohibiting AI, but intentionally designing and safeguarding periods of thought unmediated by AI. There must be time when students are allowed to flounder in front of a blank page, time for heading in the wrong direction, time to endure the silence when nothing comes out. Until now, education has trained students in the process of arriving at correct answers. What education should preserve in the future is the ability to endure a state without answers. This is not a matter of curriculum but of the very design of education itself.
Looking more broadly, this change blurs not only individual thinking ability but also each person's unique voice. Only in sentences that one begins on their own does something uniquely personal emerge. In the work of revising drafts written by others, who that person is rarely becomes clear. Ultimately, the real question in the age of AI is not how much AI can replace us, but what we will choose not to delegate to AI. Convenience always comes with a price; today, it is demanding from us our ability to initiate thinking. Whether at the level of universities or individuals, what must be safeguarded now is not the quality of output, but the discomfort of beginning.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Yoonsuk Son, Professor at the University of Notre Dame
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.