Whether Included in Second Phase Relocation Plan Draws Attention
Legal Revision Required Before NongHyup Can Relocate
Cost-Benefit Controversy Over Billions in Expenses

As the government prepares to announce the second phase of the public institution relocation plan, discussions regarding the possible relocation of the National Agricultural Cooperative Federation (NongHyup) headquarters to a provincial city have reignited. The labor union is signaling a large-scale rally opposing the relocation, leading to signs of escalating conflict between labor and the government. The union has made it clear that if NongHyup is included as a relocation target, it will not rule out the possibility of a general strike.


On the 18th, an official from the NH Nonghyup Branch stated, "On the 21st, we will hold a protest with around 200 union members in front of the main building in Seodaemun, and then march to the Blue House to strongly protest any plans to relocate NongHyup to a provincial city." The official added, "We firmly believe that relocating NongHyup is not a matter that can be negotiated based on conditions or timing; it is absolutely unacceptable." The official further explained, "Although we remain cautious since the government's second phase relocation plan for public institutions has not yet been announced, if NongHyup is designated for relocation, we will take action to block it," emphasizing that a general strike is being considered if necessary.


On the 11th, NH Nonghyup Branch held a 'Full-scale Struggle Resolution Rally to Prevent Local Relocation' together with the Korea Development Bank Branch, Industrial Bank of Korea Branch, and Export-Import Bank of Korea Branch on Uisadang-daero beside the Korea Development Bank headquarters in Yeouido, Seoul. NH Nonghyup Branch

On the 11th, NH Nonghyup Branch held a 'Full-scale Struggle Resolution Rally to Prevent Local Relocation' together with the Korea Development Bank Branch, Industrial Bank of Korea Branch, and Export-Import Bank of Korea Branch on Uisadang-daero beside the Korea Development Bank headquarters in Yeouido, Seoul. NH Nonghyup Branch

View original image

◆ "Seoul Headquarters" Stipulated in the NongHyup Act...Law Must Be Changed to Permit Relocation= The National Agricultural Cooperative Federation is legally distinct from ordinary public institutions. It is a cooperative established with equity contributions from its member cooperatives, and key decisions—such as the appointment and dismissal of executives, business plans, and budgeting—are made through the General Assembly and the Council of Delegates, both of which are composed of member cooperatives. Article 114 of the current Agricultural Cooperative Association Act stipulates, "The Federation shall have its principal office in Seoul Metropolitan City and may have branch and liaison offices as prescribed by its Articles of Association." This is why the NongHyup Act itself must be revised before the headquarters can be relocated to a provincial city. A proposed amendment to the NongHyup Act, currently pending in the National Assembly, seeks to allow the location of the principal office (currently specified as Seoul) to be determined through the Articles of Association. The amendment also requires consideration of balanced national development when deciding office locations or establishing additional offices. During the previous 21st National Assembly, there were four bills proposing to permit such a change, but they were discarded when the session ended.


NongHyup Headquarters Relocation Debate Reignites...Union Warns of Possible General Strike View original image

◆"Not Even a Public Institution"...The Government's Legal Basis for Relocation Demands= NongHyup does not meet the requirements for designation as a public institution under the Act on the Management of Public Institutions. A National Assembly review also pointed out that requiring the relocation of NongHyup headquarters for balanced national development may not align with the Federation’s founding purpose as a cooperative. However, there are precedents of other organizations—such as the National Forestry Cooperative Federation, National Credit Union Federation, and National Mutual Savings Banks Federation—delegating the determination of their main office location to the Articles of Association to allow for relocation, despite having laws originally requiring a Seoul headquarters. While revising the law for NongHyup is not impossible, the real conflict lies in balancing the autonomy of a cooperative with broader policy goals such as balanced national development.


NongHyup Headquarters Relocation Debate Reignites...Union Warns of Possible General Strike View original image

◆Moving Over 1,000 People...Thousands of Billions of Won—Cost vs. Benefit Argument= The cost issue is also significant. NongHyup operates about 190 regional organizations nationwide, including regional headquarters and city and county branches. When including training centers and overseas offices, there are over 200 branches and liaison offices. The entire NongHyup group workforce is approximately 96,000 people, with about 2,900 at the headquarters. Of these, an estimated 1,167 employees work at the Seoul main office. Analysts note that the fiscal benefits to local governments from such a relocation would be minimal. For example, in 2024, the National Agricultural Cooperative Federation paid around 3.6 billion won in local property, resident, and automobile taxes to Seoul. In contrast, relocation expenses could be substantial. According to a 2016 National Assembly Budget Office analysis, previous cases showed relocation costs ranging from 250 million won to 500 million won per person. Applying 300 million won per person, relocating all 1,167 staff members from the Seoul headquarters alone would require approximately 350 billion won. Additional expenses—such as acquiring new office space, assisting staff with housing and education, and covering productivity losses—could further increase costs. The union claims that, in reality, only about 460 employees out of the 1,167 at the headquarters could feasibly be relocated.



◆"To Our Region"...The Choice of Relocation Site as Another Flashpoint= The destination itself is another contentious issue. As of March 2025, NongHyup has 1,111 member cooperatives and 294 delegates. The delegates’ council is responsible for key decisions such as amending the Articles of Association, electing executives, approving business plans, and confirming settlements instead of the General Assembly. If the relocation becomes a reality, competition among regional member cooperatives across the country to attract the headquarters will likely intensify. Because NongHyup is based on national farmers and regional cooperatives, efforts to select the new location may result in intense conflicts of interest among member cooperatives.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing