Winner-Takes-All Politics Deepens Divisions: The Naked Truth of Korea 81 Years After Liberation
Rapid Upheaval in Judiciary: Supreme Court Expansion, Constitutional Appeal System
Prosecution Dismantled, Special Counsel Powers Expanded: A Reshuff

[Ask The Era] Kim Okgyun's Sword, Yun Dongju's Pen... And Today's Korea View original image

On that day 81 years ago, the entire nation was united as one. The waves of liberation shook the country to its core, with people of all ages flooding the streets. In that moment of mixed tears and cheers, no one asked which side you were on. There was no need to ask, no reason to care. Liberation itself was a singular, united feeling.


Now, after 81 years, this country is deeply divided. For thousands of years, we have carried on as one people, sharing the same culture and traditions. We enjoy advanced civilization fit for the era of artificial intelligence, boast top-tier economic power, and have the highest university admission rates in the world. Yet, if you look inside, it is hard to see us as one community. People only talk to those who agree with them; otherwise, suspicion and distrust prevail. Trust, mutual growth, compromise, and concession are becoming things of another world. This Liberation Day was no different. While an impressive official ceremony took place with only a select few attendees, angry voices from all over the country filled central Seoul. One side drew massive media coverage, while the other was barely mentioned. You begin to wonder if we are really the descendants of those who cried out “Mansei” in unison from corner to corner of the land 81 years ago. How did things end up like this? The causes are clear and the reasons are simple.


Rather than leading national unity, reconciliation, and cooperation, politics has driven us in the opposite direction. Structurally, the winner-takes-all election system means that winning even a single extra vote brings total power, while losing means losing everything. Survival forces politicians to solidify their base and overpower the opposition, escalating confrontation and conflict into hatred and hostility. The problem is that those at the pinnacle of political power actively fuel this system. The higher you go, the more you see, enjoy, and control. Far from persuading radical loyalists caught up in group egotism, politicians use them as a support base to stir up hardline tactics, shamelessly shifting their words with time and place, displaying duplicity and hypocrisy. As Korean politics evolves further into a rigid food chain, the inside rots. This is why some informed citizens even call Korean politics “the center of evil.”


In this gloomy reality, two historical figures come to mind: Kim Okgyun (1851–1894) and Yun Dongju (1917–1945). Both lived in unfortunate times and died abroad. One took up the sword, the other the pen. The former was a revolutionary who tried to topple the old order to build a modern nation; the latter was a poet who longed to live an honorable life even in the darkness of colonial rule. Their methods were different, but their aims were clear.


Kim Okgyun dreamed of breaking down hereditary class divisions, removing the barriers of status, and employing talent according to merit. He also envisioned severe punishment of corrupt officials and implementing fair taxation. Even though these ideas are more than 140 years old, they do not seem outdated or faded today.


Yun Dongju did not write political manifestos. With the hope of “not feeling a single shame while looking up at the sky until the day I die,” Yun, a poet who lived through a harsh era when his people suffered, even felt ashamed that “poems come so easily” and shuddered at the thought. The intense spirit born out of a young intellectual’s self-reflection—that is why his poetry still lives within us today. But what does the Republic of Korea look like on the 81st anniversary of liberation? Over the past year or so, the National Assembly has moved at a breathtaking pace. The number of Supreme Court Justices was increased from 14 to 26 (through the Court Organization Act); a new law (the Judicial Distortion Crime) enables criminal prosecution of judges whose rulings are found unsatisfactory; and, a new system (judicial complaint) allowing the Constitutional Court to overturn court rulings—all these were unilaterally pushed through in just three days.


The foundations of the judicial system, maintained for the 39 years since democratization in 1987, have been thrown into turmoil. Even when the Chief Justice called for deliberation, stating this was a constitutional issue, and court presidents across the country expressed regrets about the lack of sufficient public debate and deliberation, it had no effect. In Germany, the Judicial Distortion Crime has been refined over 150 years of case law, yet its application is still debated. In the United Kingdom, even after breaking with centuries of tradition where the upper house of parliament also served as the highest court, it took more than four years of preparation before the independent Supreme Court opened in 2009. Since the founding of the Republic of Korea, the prosecution service has now reached a stage of de facto dismantlement, and under the pretext of separating investigation and prosecution, countless special prosecutors—highly politicized—are now being vested with investigative powers, even granting them the authority to dismiss indictments in cases involving the president. The integration of the Army, Navy, and Air Force academies—long symbols and pillars of national defense over the past 80 years—was also decided after only a token procedure. Institutions and symbols that have supported the nation are being restructured in rapid succession, but no one clearly explains or understands the meaning and reasons. Even the attraction of AI semiconductor facilities—so key to future industries—to the Honam region, as the government itself has admitted, was more of a political decision than a corporate one, but crucial infrastructure plans like electricity and water supply remain uncertain. Priorities and decision-makers have been turned upside down.


What is so urgent? Who, exactly, is chasing us? If we aspire to liberal democracy and uphold parliamentary democracy, then issues related to the separation of powers or major national policies require repeated debate, research, public understanding, and consensus. That is the proper and sensible course. However, now, anyone who voices opposition is immediately branded as anti-reform and the discussion abruptly ends. Criticism is labeled obstruction, deliberation is dismissed as inefficiency, and due process becomes a mere formality. In such an environment, we can already guess how cases involving the indictment of the president would conclude. What will come next?


History has already left its warnings. Hitler in Germany did not seize power through a coup, but by achieving the largest party in an election, and was lawfully appointed Chancellor in 1933. The passage of the Enabling Act through parliamentary vote then transferred legislative power to the executive branch. The Weimar Constitution remained in name only, its functions suspended. The legislature and elections still existed, but neither could control power. Thus, democracy can collapse not by guns and bayonets, but by procedures and majority rule, even when cloaked in legality. The most insidious and dangerous collapse is when only the forms remain and all substance is lost.


Kim Okgyun’s reform was just, but much too hasty. He lost public support and his efforts collapsed in just three days. Yet today’s powers act even more impatiently, emboldened by far greater authority and organization. Watching anti-democratic measures being forced through in the name of reform, it becomes clear why Kim Okgyun is being reappraised today.


Back to reality—what are the opposition parties and social leaders doing? At most, the opposition clings to a so-called “filibuster”—a 24-hour continuing debate. The term is borrowed from the United States, but the practice is nothing like it. In America, the filibuster is a tool to force the majority party to negotiate. In Korea, it has become little more than a sideshow rationalizing unilateral passage of bills by the majority. Once that ends, internal squabbles keep lawmakers up all night, spiraling into self-destruction, much like the falling approval ratings of the president.



Protests from the legal community end with statements that echo in vain, media criticism cannot turn back the bills, and warnings from academia are lost in the noise. Even citizens once holding candles watch, in silence and apathy, as democracy crumbles from within. Freedom of expression is shrinking. The so-called “fake news prevention law,” enacted in July, claims to regulate false information, but in reality, it is a law that muzzles voices. Both AP and the Financial Times have pointed this out. Among younger generations, indirect speech such as “they say that…” is spreading to avoid making definitive statements. The memory overlaps with the fate of Yun Dongju, who became a prisoner of the times for the act of writing poetry in the Korean language and ultimately died in cold anonymity. That most of his Korean poems disappeared in the Japanese prison is a heartbreaking tragedy. Now, power forgets not only shame but even the very word “self-reflection,” attacking the opposition with the language of hate and hostility. As Yun Dongju reflected deeper, he grew only more ashamed of himself. Did he count the stars and sing of hope, thinking that one day the blue grass would blanket the mound where his name is buried, as a proud emblem, when spring returns after winter, and that his unworthy descendants would look up at the stars? I cannot lift my head to gaze at the stars. If Liberation Day is more than a commemoration of Korea’s 1945 independence, then what is it that we must truly set free today? Is it not liberal democracy itself, trapped under the misleading name of reform? The direction pointed out by Kim Okgyun’s sword and Yun Dongju’s pen—81 years on, we must urgently and profoundly ask ourselves this question once again. Kim Hyong-O, former Speaker of the National Assembly


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing