Sharp Disagreement Over Lowering the Age Standard for Criminal Minors

A video showing a teenage student unleashing a torrent of profanity and threats at a police officer has been released, sparking controversy.


A video of a teenage student swearing at a police officer sparked controversy. YouTube screenshot

A video of a teenage student swearing at a police officer sparked controversy. YouTube screenshot

View original image

On August 15, the YouTube channel "Kingbadjyu" uploaded a Shorts video titled "Arrests Have Become Social Media Content for Today's Teens." The video, originally posted on August 8, features a scene filmed by a student in the back seat of a police car. The student is seen with handcuffs on both wrists. When the police officer inquires about the student's age, the student replies, "I was born in 2012, you [expletive]." When the officer asks again, "If you were born in 2012, how old are you?" the student retorts, "I'm in eighth grade, you [expletive], think about it. You messed with me first, right? I haven't laid a hand on you, I only used words. I’ll make you pay [expletives]. Answer me, you [expletive]." The student continued to hurl profanities and threats.


When the officer tried to quiet the student, saying it was too loud, the student continued, "Go ahead and do it, you [expletive]. You want me to mess with your parents too?" again uttering threats and profanities.


The student, who stated he was born in 2012 and whose birthday has not yet passed this year, would be considered, under current law, a criminal minor (“juvenile under the law”). This term refers to minors between the ages of 10 and under 14 who, under current legislation, are not subject to criminal punishment.


For “juveniles under the law” aged 10 to 13, police must refer all cases to the Juvenile Division of the court, where the court decides after a hearing whether to impose protective measures (categories 1 through 10) or take no further action. Juvenile offenders aged 14 to 18 undergo police and prosecutorial investigation before potentially being referred to the juvenile court or facing criminal trial. If brought to criminal court, they may face criminal penalties such as imprisonment or a suspended sentence.


At the cabinet meeting last month, the Ministry of Gender Equality and Family raised the possibility of lowering the age threshold for “juveniles under the law” from “10 and older to under 14” to “10 and older to under 13” for serious, major, or repeat crimes. After receiving this report, President Lee Jaemyung said, "It seems necessary to lower [the age standard for juveniles under the law]," but also instructed, "Let’s seek public opinion again."



However, this topic remains controversial among politicians and child rights advocates. Kim Yoom, head of the National Center for the Rights of the Child, stated on July 22, "From the perspective of protecting children's rights, the UN recommends age 14" and opposed lowering the standard. Forty-three human rights organizations also strongly objected, stating that "lowering the age standard for juveniles under the law would roll back children's rights and run counter to child-friendly judicial principles." A joint public-private consultative body has called for a comprehensive review, citing the need to assess statistical evidence, the characteristics of youth development, protective and correctional infrastructure, and more, before deciding on whether and how much to lower the age standard. They added that along with any adjustment to the age standard, improvements throughout the juvenile justice system are essential, including expanding protective facilities, increasing professional staff, and strengthening victim protection.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing