[Reporter’s Notebook] The True Nature of the Sinan County Town Hall Meeting Obscured by Political Framing
Political Frame Overshadowing Residents’ Voices:
The Real Issues Behind Sinan County’s Landscaping Tree Project Town Hall
Media Focuses on Political Legacies While Overlooking Public Concerns and Policy Substance
In Sinan County, part of Jeonnam Gwangju Integrated Special City, the local government recently held a town hall meeting to directly engage with residents and discuss key local issues. However, some media outlets have come under criticism for distorting the substance of the debate over the landscaping tree project by framing the discussion as an attempt to erase the achievements of the previous county governor.
The forum, which was intended to disclose the problems of the landscaping tree project and hear residents' opinions, suddenly became a political battleground between the former and current county governors.
Media coverage focused heavily on the backlash from certain residents and stakeholders involved in the landscaping tree project. In contrast, these outlets failed to sufficiently address why Sinan County publicly raised the landscaping tree project as an agenda item, how much budget had been invested in the program to date, or what kinds of civil complaints had arisen regarding roadside trees.
According to the county, a total of KRW 134.7 billion has been spent on the landscaping tree project from 2018 up to this year.
Despite this significant expenditure, ongoing complaints have been reported from some areas: trees blocking drivers’ vision, disrupting sunlight and ventilation for farmland, and hampering the movement of farm equipment. There have also been criticisms that the excessive density of planted trees has prevented proper growth while only adding to maintenance costs.
In circumstances like this, it is sound governance to publicly disclose both the achievements and problems of the project to residents, and to seek their input on the way forward.
If a project led by a former county governor is left unchecked solely for that reason, this is the very definition of irresponsible governance. Good policies should be continued; those with identified problems should be corrected, which is the responsibility of the new county governor and public officials.
Nonetheless, some media interpreted this policy review solely as an attempt to erase past achievements.
Such reporting prioritizes political conflict over the reality of the landscaping tree project. The articles did not clearly state who actually claimed it was an “erasure of legacy,” whether this opinion represented the majority of residents, or whether it was mainly the view of certain interested parties in seedling production and procurement.
In particular, it is known that some of those speaking at the town hall were stakeholders directly or indirectly tied to the Landscaping Tree Cooperative or to seedling production.
Of course, the voices of stakeholders should be respected. However, presenting the opinions of these individuals as if they reflect the general sentiment of all county residents—without disclosing their direct interest in the project—can only lead viewers and readers to misunderstand the facts.
The claims of interested parties, who would profit if the county purchases their seedlings, and the voices of residents who have suffered agricultural or transportation disadvantages due to the landscaping tree project, must be clearly distinguished from each other.
Some media outlets emphasized the former group, but downplayed the concerns of the latter and the accumulated issues associated with the project.
This raises serious questions as to whether such coverage qualifies as balanced reporting.
Moreover, at the town hall, County Governor Kim Taeseong outlined measures such as prioritizing the use of seedlings produced by small-scale farms and seeking out additional planting locations beyond those previously considered.
He did not announce any plans to dissolve the Landscaping Tree Cooperative or to completely halt the purchase of seedlings. Instead, while reviewing the issues that emerged during the project, he offered a realistic compromise to protect small farms suffering the greatest harm.
Nevertheless, some reports focused almost exclusively on residents’ opposition, framing the event as if the current county administration was primarily trying to eliminate the previous governor’s signature policy.
Even when small-farm protection measures were part of the coverage, the headline and conclusion still centered on an “erasure of legacy.” In effect, the weight of fact and political interpretation was reversed.
The town hall’s greatest significance was that residents could directly question—and challenge—the county governor and responsible officials.
There were residents who spoke in favor of the landscaping tree project, cooperative officials who loudly expressed distrust in the administration’s explanations, and public criticisms of the relevant departments were also made openly.
Such scenes could not have occurred if the administration had provided only pre-determined answers or suppressed dissenting voices. In fact, the fact that vocal opposition was publicized demonstrates that Sinan County authorities included dissenting views in the forum.
The process of residents demanding accountability directly from the governor and officials, and receiving public answers in return, is the essence of communicative governance. Accepting every demand as-is is not the only definition of communication.
True communication means listening to residents' opinions, reviewing the law and budget, reflecting feasible requests in government policy, and explaining the reasons if other requests cannot be met.
The same applies to the landscaping tree project.
The claims of farms, which state they produced seedlings based on the county’s official letters, and the administration’s counterpoint that no formal purchase agreement was made, should be clarified through objective data.
Issues such as the ownership of seedlings left with farms, payment of land lease fees, and the circumstances of external seedling purchases must also be verified. Likewise, the cooperative should transparently disclose their production and sales volumes, reliance on county purchases, and track record in private sales channels.
Such fact-checking is a prerequisite for accurately determining responsibility and improvement measures for the landscaping tree project. Yet, some media outlets have prioritized political rhetoric about “erasing the previous governor’s legacy” over the necessary scrutiny of contracts, implementation documents, budget execution, and tree management status.
Simplifying complex policy issues into a conflict between current and former governors may make for easy and sensational reporting—but in doing so, the true voices of residents are lost and only the political narrative remains.
The role of the local media is not to defend any particular politician’s achievements, nor to blindly support the new administration’s policies.
The foremost concern must be to verify whether taxpayers’ money has been effectively used, whether the project truly benefited residents, and whether administrative procedures were properly followed.
Equating a public review of a KRW 134.7 billion landscaping tree project with political retribution or an erasure of legacy means the discussion becomes captivated by political interpretation, rather than the reality of the project itself.
No one can claim that the county’s town hall event was perfect.
Criticism that the administration failed to adequately address the cooperative members’ concerns over official letters, seedling ownership, land lease fees, and external procurement must be answered through subsequent data disclosure and further debate.
The process should not end at gathering residents’ opinions, but should also involve publicizing how those opinions were incorporated into actual policy decisions.
However, labeling the very intent of the town hall as an “erasure of the previous governor’s legacy” solely because of some shortcomings is an excessive political interpretation.
This town hall event matters precisely because it did not shy away from sensitive issues, but instead brought them out into the open before residents.
Microphones were offered even to opposing residents, and public answers were provided by the county governor and officials. Proposals were also made to both protect small-scale farms and make use of existing seedlings.
Shining a light on a policy’s weaknesses and searching for solutions with residents is not an act of erasure.
This is a sign of administrative change—correcting what is wrong and reflecting residents’ voices in county policies.
While some media are preoccupied with applying a political frame, the real substance—what residents actually demanded at the town hall, and how Sinan County plans to translate these demands into policy—has faded to the background.
What the media ought to focus on is not whether the previous county governor’s legacy is erased.
Instead, it should be whether the voices of residents from the town hall meetings are being reflected in actual county policy, and if the problems found in a project funded with KRW 134.7 billion are being properly resolved.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
The standard for judging whether an administration truly belongs to its people should not be a political frame—but the lived realities of the residents themselves.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.