Constitutional Council Acknowledges Need for Youth Protection
President Instructs Preparation of New Draft Bill

France imposed a ban on the use of social networking services (SNS) by youths under the age of 15, but the country's constitutional review body has ruled that the bill violates the Constitution.


"France's Strong Move to Ban SNS for Youths Halted by Unconstitutional Ruling" View original image

On August 14 local time, AFP and other outlets reported that the French Constitutional Council declared the provision banning SNS use for those under 15 years old unconstitutional.


The Constitutional Council stated, "This measure is an inappropriate, unnecessary, and disproportionate infringement on the freedom of expression and communication of youths under 15." It also explained that the age verification system required by the French government was "contrary to the principle of privacy protection, as prohibiting SNS use by a particular age group would require all users, including adults, to disclose certain information."


The council further pointed out that "among the SNS platforms the government seeks to restrict access to for minors, some have not been proven to pose a risk to the health and safety of young people."


Le Monde explained that while the original bill included exceptions for education and science, the scope of the ban became extremely broad by restricting youth access not only to TikTok and Instagram but also to the SNS features of YouTube and online video games. The council appears to have considered that even services for which risk to minors has not been demonstrated could be subject to regulation.


French Constitutional Council. Photo by AFP Yonhap News

French Constitutional Council. Photo by AFP Yonhap News

View original image

However, the Constitutional Council did not deny the necessity of protecting youths from the dangers of SNS. As a result, some interpret that government or parliament could adopt SNS regulations if the laws are designed in a more precise and restrictive manner.


The Macron administration, which has been actively pursuing a ban on SNS use by minors, is disappointed by this ruling. The French presidential office, the Elysée Palace, stated, "The president has instructed the prime minister to prepare a robust draft bill as quickly as possible, taking into account the Constitutional Council's decision and the European Union's legal framework," and emphasized, "The president's determination to achieve this reform by next spring remains unwavering."



Previously, on July 21, the French parliament passed the bill prohibiting SNS use for those under 15, making France the first country in Europe to do so after Australia. According to the bill, starting September 1, when the new school year begins, minors are prohibited from opening SNS accounts, and platforms must close existing children's accounts by early next year. The bill also included a ban on mobile phone use in high schools. However, the Constitutional Council did not review this provision.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing