Gyeonggi Province Governor Choo Mi-ae has countered claims that the province's debt-to-budget ratio is actually better than that of Seoul or Busan, following her recent declaration of a "Fiscal State of Emergency" in Gyeonggi Province. She dismissed such assertions as "merely hollow indicators that look plausible only as numbers."


She particularly compared the province’s situation to "living on advance pay," emphasizing that the rate of debt increase in Gyeonggi Province over the past three years has been about three times higher than that of other metropolitan governments nationwide. She also pointed out the instability of the revenue structure, which heavily depends on acquisition tax, warning, "The gray rhino is standing right in front of us."


On the 14th, Governor Choo explained the risks to Gyeonggi Province's finances by likening them to personal household finances, in a post on her social networking service (SNS) titled "Please Truly Understand and Evaluate the Reality of Gyeonggi Province."


Governor Choo asked, "If you have loans, but the borrowed money has already been spent on living expenses and you don’t have enough assets, and your monthly fixed expenses keep increasing while your anticipated salary going forward is not stable, can you really say, 'There's nothing to worry about because the loan isn't due yet'?"


She continued, "That is exactly the situation with Gyeonggi Province's finances right now," claiming, "If this continues, there will be a fiscal collapse and a default." She then questioned, "Yet should we really do nothing about it?"


Governor Choo first addressed claims that Gyeonggi Province's debt-to-budget ratio is healthier than that of Seoul or Busan, labeling it a "hollow indicator that only looks plausible on paper." The debt-to-budget ratio shows how much local government debt exists compared to the annual budget. As of the end of 2025, Gyeonggi Province's debt is about 6.1 trillion won, with a debt-to-budget ratio in the 12% range.


She noted, "If you just look at this number, it might seem manageable," but added, "When judging a person’s debt, we don’t just compare salary and loan amount." One should also consider assets, monthly disposable income, the stability of future earnings, and actual repayment ability.


She especially highlighted the debt-to-asset ratio as a major vulnerability of Gyeonggi Province's finances. The province's debt-to-asset ratio is 15.3%, the highest among all provinces and metropolitan cities nationwide. As of 2024, Gyeonggi's assets stand at about 43.3 trillion won, with debt at approximately 6.6 trillion won.


She also pointed out that Seoul has assets of about 150 trillion won, Incheon about 64 trillion won, and Busan about 50 trillion won, all of which are higher than Gyeonggi Province. Based on this, she argued, "The scale of the household is large, but the debt carried is heavier relative to the assets held."


She then raised an issue with the speed at which Gyeonggi’s debt is increasing.


On the 14th, Gyeonggi Province Governor Choo Mi-ae posted on her SNS.

On the 14th, Gyeonggi Province Governor Choo Mi-ae posted on her SNS.

View original image

Between 2023 and 2025, the total debt of metropolitan governments nationwide rose from about 36.7 trillion won to 41.5 trillion won, an increase of 12.7%. During the same period, Gyeonggi Province's debt grew from around 4.5 trillion won to 6.1 trillion won, an increase of 36.1%.


Governor Choo pointed out, "While nationwide metropolitan government debt increased by 12.7%, Gyeonggi Province's debt grew by 36.1%, nearly three times faster." She described this as "Gyeonggi living on advance pay," expressing concern over the rapid debt growth.


She also criticized the unstable nature of the province's revenue structure. Governor Choo claimed that about half of Gyeonggi Province's local tax revenue this year relies on acquisition tax, highlighting a higher dependency compared to Seoul at 23.5% and Daejeon at 21%. Since acquisition tax is heavily affected by real estate transactions and economic shifts, high reliance on this particular tax can lead to greater revenue volatility.


She said, "There is little discretionary money, and even incoming funds are unstable," calling this "the greatest weakness of Gyeonggi Province’s finances." She added, "We have to repay our debts, but the structure for earning that money is itself unstable."


Governor Choo also pointed out that Gyeonggi Province faces considerable future fiscal demands. With the highest number of newborns in the country and a rapidly increasing and incoming senior population, ongoing spending in welfare and public livelihood areas will likely surge.


She likened the current fiscal situation in Gyeonggi Province to a "gray rhino," a metaphor for risks that are highly likely and well-recognized, yet inadequately addressed.



In closing, Governor Choo declared, "As the governor responsible for the lives and taxes of 14.2 million residents, I want to ask: What choice should I make?"


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing