Pro-Japanese Asset Confiscation Resumes After 16 Years... Is Recovery Possible for Ha Young and Ahn Sangho's Assets?
Pro-Japanese Asset Confiscation Resumes in December
Not a Revision, But in Effect an Entirely New Law
Assets Accumulated Through Medical Practice Likely Excluded
Confiscation of Ha Young’s Personal Assets Not Possible
As controversy grows surrounding pro-Japanese allegations involving actor Ha Young's great-grandfather, Dr. Sangho Ahn, some people are now calling for “the recovery of assets acquired through pro-Japanese collaboration from descendants.” However, there is a clear distinction between confirming pro-Japanese activities and whether assets can actually be reclaimed. To begin with, there are multiple records that demonstrate Sangho Ahn’s pro-Japanese actions.
In 1909, he was listed as a member of the preparatory committee for a memorial service held after An Jung-geun's assassination of Hirobumi Ito, and was active in organizations such as Dongminhoe and Daejeong Friendship Association, which promoted harmony between Japan and Joseon. In 1918, Maeil Shinbo, the official newspaper of the Japanese Government-General of Korea, featured his family as an example of an ‘Ilseondongche’ household, having adopted a Japanese lifestyle.
However, Sangho Ahn does not appear on the official list of 1,006 individuals identified by the Presidential Committee for the Investigation of Pro-Japanese and Anti-National Activities, nor in the “Dictionary of Pro-Japanese Figures” issued by the Institute for Research in Collaborationist Activities, which contains 4,389 names. The Institute explained that while Sangho Ahn did engage in some pro-Japanese conduct, he was excluded because his actions lacked the level of active engagement and repeated behavior required by their then-criteria.
Pro-Japanese Asset Recovery Restarts in December... Will It Apply to Sangho Ahn?
The Constitutional Court ruled long ago that “retroactive legislation” to reclaim assets from pro-Japanese collaborators is constitutional. Accordingly, beginning December 3, the government will implement a new pro-Japanese asset recovery regime. Investigative procedures will resume after the previous Pro-Japanese Property Investigation Committee ended 16 years ago. The new law has also broadened the scope of recovery. Even if property acquired through pro-Japanese collaboration has already been sold to a third party and the property itself cannot be returned, the government may claim the disposal proceeds if certain conditions are met.
A family photo of Sangho Ahn, introduced as a model family of the concept "Naeseonilche" and "Ilseondonghwa," which means Japan and Joseon are one. National Library of Korea
View original imageThat said, this does not mean Sangho Ahn’s assets will be subject to immediate recovery. First, an investigative committee must determine whether Sangho Ahn’s actions amount to significant pro-Japanese and anti-national activities sufficient to legally permit reclamation. Simply participating in a pro-Japanese organization does not automatically subject all of one’s assets to recovery. Most crucial is how the property was originally acquired.
According to the law, among assets acquired by pro-Japanese collaborators after the start of the Russo–Japanese War in 1904, those received as compensation for cooperation with the Japanese authorities are defined as “pro-Japanese property.” While property obtained during this period may be presumed to have been acquired in return for collaboration, it can be excluded from recovery if it can be proven that the fortune was amassed through legitimate economic activity.
Since Sangho Ahn operated a private medical clinic at the time, the main issue in any investigation is expected to be whether he received land or assets as special favors from the Japanese authorities, or whether he gained his fortune legitimately through medical and business practice.
Could Assets Earned by Descendant Ha Young Also Be Reclaimed?
Meanwhile, a faction of internet users insists even the assets of descendants should be reclaimed. However, pro-Japanese asset recovery is not a system that punishes descendants. The law enables the state to reclaim specific assets acquired by an ancestor as compensation for pro-Japanese collaboration, if such property—or its proceeds—has been passed on to the next generation. Therefore, appearance fees, advertising income, or personally acquired real estate and savings that Ha Young earned from her acting career cannot be reclaimed solely because of her great-grandfather’s pro-Japanese actions.
Earlier, Ha Young revealed on the July 7th episode of KBS 2TV entertainment show "Problem Children of the Rooftop Room" that she comes from a family of doctors spanning four generations. KBS
View original imageThe Constitution also prohibits so-called guilt by association, in which relatives are punished for the actions of their family members. Ultimately, there are three key issues to address in the Sangho Ahn case: First, whether his pro-Japanese actions are recognized under the new special law as serious enough to trigger property confiscation; second, how he actually accumulated his assets after 1904; and third, whether those assets were a reward for collaboration and in what form they have been inherited or disposed of up to the present day.
Based on currently available records, although much of Sangho Ahn’s pro-Japanese background can be confirmed, it is difficult to conclude that Ha Young or her family’s current assets can actually be reclaimed. While historical assessment of pro-Japanese conduct must be rigorous, reclaiming property depends on separate legal standards and specific records of fortune formation.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Given that nearly 100 years have passed, it will be necessary to trace records of registration, inheritance, and sale—and, because assets may have changed form through multiple rounds of inheritance or disposal, any investigation will likely face significant difficulties. During the activities of the now-defunct Pro-Japanese Property Investigation Committee, the main challenge cited was uncovering the origins and ownership of old assets.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.