Shinan County Seeks to Minimize Cooperative Members' Losses in 'Ornamental Tree Procurement Project'
Concerns Grow Over Potential Losses from Sapling Purchases Under This Year’s 18 Billion Won Project Plan
Remedies Considered Include Utilizing Saplings for Other Public Projects and Sales to Forestry Cooperatives
Shinan County, designated as part of the Gwangju-Jeonnam Special Integrated City, has begun taking practical measures such as legal review and exploring remedies including the use of public projects and external sales. This follows growing concerns among Jeongwon Fisheries Cooperative members, who have already acquired saplings, after the issue of split single-source contracts in the ornamental tree procurement project—initiated in the 8th civilian administration—was pointed out during an audit.
A member of Jeongwon Cooperative asking Kim Taesung, Shinangun County Governor, a question during the town hall meeting held on the 13th. Screenshot from Kim Taesung TV video.
View original imageThe county announced plans to thoroughly examine the legality of the project’s implementation process regarding the recent controversy over Jeongwon Cooperative’s sapling procurement, and to develop a variety of solutions so that bona fide cooperative members are not unfairly harmed.
This issue began when Shinan County’s Department of Garden Forestry sent an official notice titled "2026 Ornamental Tree Procurement Plan for the Creation of One Island, One Garden Blooming All Year Round" to the Jeongwon Fisheries Cooperative on September 22 last year.
The plan at that time called for planting approximately 1.24 million ornamental trees in 13 towns and townships, excluding Heuksando, from February to December 2026. This would be part of 12 national and provincial subsidized projects, such as island roadside gardens, environmental forests, and local gardens, with an investment of 18 billion won.
The species scheduled for planting included more than 30 types, such as glasswort, barberry, crape myrtle, wild peach, trifoliate orange, birch, hydrangea, and others.
Previously, under the 8th administration, Shinan County promoted the purchase of ornamental trees through a social cooperative: 19 billion won for 22 species in 2024 and 18.8 billion won for 39 species in 2025.
Subsequently, the county planned to purchase approximately 1.24 million ornamental trees worth about 18 billion won in 2026, indicating a steady expansion of related projects.
However, it has been found that, for the 2026 project, no budget for ornamental tree purchases was included in the main budget, nor were the subsequent administrative procedures necessary for actual project implementation initiated.
Notably, during the audit conducted in July by the superior inspection agency on Shinan County’s ornamental tree project and related matters, problems with the type of contract signed with the Jeongwon Fisheries Cooperative were also revealed.
According to the audit results, Shinan County entered into single-source contracts totaling about 39.9 billion won with the cooperative for the garden project. In this process, the contract amount per agreement was divided into sums of 50 million won or less, resulting in a total of 939 contracts.
As this split single-source contract approach has been flagged in the contract process, where compliance with the Local Contract Act and other relevant laws is required, further audits of the overall ornamental tree procurement and planting project are expected.
As a result, the issue of potential losses for cooperative members who had already acquired saplings based on the county’s procurement plans has emerged as a new concern.
The county authorities see it as realistically difficult to repurchase saplings held by coop members under the previously problematic split contract method, and are seeking lawful, alternative ways to minimize damages.
In particular, the county drew a clear line regarding claims from some quarters that "the return of national funds by Shinan County caused financial losses to cooperative members," stating that such claims are not directly related to the current sapling issue.
A county official explained, "The claim about returning national funds, which some Jeongwon Fisheries Cooperative members are making, is unrelated to this matter. Based on a comprehensive review of site suitability and legal status of the original project location, difficulty in securing alternative sites, and consultations with relevant agencies, we determined that normal project execution would be difficult and are thus considering returning the project budget—a separate issue."
Going forward, the county plans to closely examine the relevant laws and contract procedures, seek legal counsel from its advisory lawyers, and establish remedies to minimize damage to cooperative members.
Options under consideration include, first, using the already-grown saplings for other public projects through legal procedures. The county is also looking at selling or transferring the trees to related agencies or forest cooperatives.
However, since the split single-source contract issue was highlighted in the audit, determining the facts and responsibility for past project contract procedures is expected to proceed separately based on future audit results, regardless of compensation for affected members.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Kim Taesung, Governor of Shinan County, emphasized, "Before debating right and wrong, our priority is to resolve the situation in which many county residents are suffering. Within the bounds of law and principle, we will actively consider a wide range of solutions to reach an amicable resolution."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.