Joonkyung Lee, Head of Honam Reporting Headquarters.

Joonkyung Lee, Head of Honam Reporting Headquarters.

View original image

The unified application deadline of the Ministry of Education, set for the 20th, is just around the corner. However, negotiations over attracting the unified medical school in the Jeonnam region have virtually come to a halt. While neighboring North Gyeongsang Province is smoothly moving forward and finalizing the attraction of a new medical school, Jeonnam is being ensnared in a protracted power struggle, ultimately shattering its own prospects.


Who drove the negotiations to ruin? Words may be impressive, but actions do not lie. A review of the negotiation process makes it abundantly clear that the two universities have chosen dramatically different paths.

The Two Faces of Action... Mokpo National University's Concessions, Sunchon National University's Escalating Demands

Mokpo National University chose principles and compromise. After agreeing in November 2024 on attracting a unified medical school, Mokpo National University continued to expand its concessions in response to the other side’s repeated use of the veto.


Abandoning its earlier position that both the medical school and the university headquarters should be in Mokpo, the university took the bold step of offering to locate the main campus in Suncheon in order to resolve a 21-year-old issue. Mokpo National University then proposed a specific operational plan for the unified university, laying out a governance structure split between the two campuses, and earnestly attended local government meetings.


In contrast, the moves made by Sunchon National University showed little regard for trust with its negotiation counterpart. Demanding new negotiations, and following Mokpo National University’s concession on the university headquarters, Sunchon National University responded with an even more elevated counterproposal.


It followed Mokpo National University’s concession on the headquarters with an official letter stating, “The medical school to Suncheon, the hospital to Suncheon first.” Immediately after issuing the counterproposal, Sunchon National University publicly announced the breakdown of negotiations in a media interview. Behind the scenes, it mobilized alumni and civic groups to hold rallies, taking the battle for public opinion outside the negotiating table.


The common sense of negotiations is to meet in the middle if one party yields. However, Sunchon National University used its counterpart’s compromises as a “weakness,” ratcheting up its own demands each time, asserting its veto at the table while focusing on swaying public sentiment outside it.

The Warning of Numbers... Political Calculations Ignoring Medical Indicators

The core of determining the location for the new medical school should be ‘equitable access to healthcare’ in the region. Numbers do not lie. A look at the healthcare indicators for Mokpo and Suncheon shows clearly which is more aligned with the state objective of ‘addressing underserved medical areas’.


First, the avoidable mortality rate—deaths that could have been prevented with timely care—is 53.93 per 100,000 for Mokpo, 14% higher than Suncheon’s 47.25. The proportion of critical patients who are unable to arrive at a major hospital within 180 minutes is also far worse in Mokpo, standing at 12.37%, which is 3.6 times higher than Suncheon’s 3.37%.


Medical spending leaking outside the region, caused by inadequate medical infrastructure, is also much greater in Mokpo: a staggering 1.114 trillion won, far exceeding Suncheon’s 896.9 billion won. If the goal of national policy is to fill the gap in emergency and essential healthcare, then by objective measures, Mokpo is the clear logical choice.


Nonetheless, Sunchon National University argued instead with vague notions of “population” and “regional aspiration,” without offering any rebuttal to the numbers. Even Chonnam National University runs its medical school and university hospital separately; Sunchon National University failed to present any medical rationale for its insistence that both the medical school and hospital be placed solely in Suncheon.


Experts have described the collapse of these negotiations as “a textbook example of how unilateral demands and media manipulation can undermine the authenticity of negotiation.” Running negotiations and public campaigns in parallel, escalating demands in response to concessions, advancing assertions lacking policy basis, and opting for off-table pressure over democratic process – these actions by Sunchon National University all serve as self-evidence that protecting current entitlements took precedence over the collective aspiration of Jeonnam residents to establish a unified medical school.


Should the final deadline pass on the 20th, Jeonnam is highly likely to be ultimately excluded from new medical school allocations. Mokpo will claim, “We made concessions,” while Suncheon will blame “Mokpo’s greed.” Local authorities and the government may trade blame and step back altogether.



Yet, one fact remains clear: self-interested intransigence by the universities has denied Jeonnam’s ailing residents the golden hours in which to receive care. Just days remain. History will record who was truly responsible for this disaster – not by their ‘words,’ but by their ‘actions.’


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing