Actor Risk Should Be Mitigated with Morals Clauses in Contracts [The Second Take]
Content Investment Faces Renewed Chill After Ha Young Controversy
The Limits of Insurance in Managing Scandal Risks
The Need for More Sophisticated Contracts with Focus on Morals Clauses
The controversy over pro-Japanese ties has engulfed actress Ha Yeong. It began when she casually mentioned on a variety show that she comes from a "family of doctors for four generations." The revelation that her great-grandfather, Ahn Sang-ho, was a council member of the Daejeong Friendship Association sparked the controversy. Her agency initially denied the allegations, but reversed its position and issued an apology the very next day. Ha Yeong also stated, "As a descendant, I sincerely apologize."
This should not be dismissed as a simple case of crisis management failure by an actor and her agency. Ha Yeong is currently co-starring with Lee Jehoon in the SBS show 'You Have a Chance.' A significant portion of filming has already been completed. Smooth broadcasting now appears unlikely. Coincidentally, another drama starring Lee Jehoon, tvN's 'Second Signal,' is also adrift, because his co-star Jo Jinwoong retired from acting following a controversy involving juvenile offenders.
The situation has brought additional trouble to the content industry. Even before this, investor sentiment was frozen. The number of dramas and films being produced is declining due to pressure on profitability and instability in recouping production costs. If a show’s broadcast is postponed indefinitely or filming is halted, investment contracts further. If the issue is such that a single actor’s personal matters result in these sunk costs, the problem is obviously even more acute.
Is there any safety net to absorb such losses? In Hollywood, there are long-standing products designed for when filming is halted by an actor’s injury or death—namely, cast insurance and completion guarantees. However, these do not cover scandal-type risks like the one involving Ha Yeong.
The sexual harassment allegations against Kevin Spacey provide a prime example. Director Ridley Scott removed Spacey’s scenes entirely from the completed film 'All the Money in the World.' The production company, Imperative Entertainment, spent 10 million dollars to reshoot the film with Christopher Plummer. This amount, which represented a quarter of the total production budget, was not covered by insurance. Netflix also wrote off 39 million dollars in losses as a result of canceling 'House of Cards' Season 6 and the Gore Vidal biopic. 'House of Cards' producer MRC tried to recover its costs through insurance, claiming that Spacey’s departure due to sex addiction treatment qualified as an illness under cast insurance. The case went to court, and the claim was reduced to 29 million dollars. This March, a jury ruled against MRC, concluding that the departure was due to public backlash, not illness.
Standard cast insurance covers death, personal injury, or illness. Losses resulting from actors causing scandals fall outside its coverage. There are insurance products dedicated to scandals, known as "disgrace insurance," but these are rare, expensive, and usually tailored to special situations like reality show cancellations—and typically only large studios can afford them. This means that even in Hollywood, insurance for scandal risks remains an unaddressed gap.
Because of these limitations, there is increasing focus in Hollywood on careful contract drafting, specifically on the inclusion and enforcement of "morals clauses." These provisions allow producers to immediately terminate or suspend contracts with cast members involved in scandals and require actors to compensate for resulting damages. The contracts may even stipulate no objection if the actor's part is reduced or entirely replaced in the finished production through editing or recasting.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Such contracting practices have yet to become standard in Korea. While indemnity and penalty clauses are generally included, the calculation methods are often vague. The 2019 court ruling ordering actor Kang Jihwan to return approximately 5.3 billion KRW to producers, after he was arrested and removed from a drama on charges of sexual assault against staff, is a rare example. The situation could improve if morals clause provisions were standardized and the scope of damages and calculation criteria clearly stipulated. Production companies may also benefit from securing the right in advance to reduce or edit out an actor’s role as a response measure.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.