[Class Action, Trap of Excessive Relief]③"Opt-Out Model Brings Adverse Effects to Korea...Need for a Korean-Style Approach"
Reference Needed to Overseas Opt-in Cases
Consider Limiting Adoption to Service and Finance Sectors
Concerns Over Violation of Trust Principle in Retroactive Application of Past Cases
As the government moves forward with the introduction of the class action law, concerns are being raised within both the business and legal sectors regarding the adoption of the American-style opt-out system, where a judgment applies to all affected parties unless individuals explicitly declare their intention to be excluded. The primary concern is that this could result in an excessive litigation burden for companies. Experts advise that, rather than unilaterally adopting the U.S. opt-out model, South Korea should look to international examples—such as Sweden, France, Germany, and Japan—which have adopted the opt-in approach, and develop a “Korean model” tailored to minimize adverse side effects.
Japan's opt-in class action procedure is conducted in two stages. In the first stage, a consumer advocacy group initiates a common obligation confirmation lawsuit against a business operator to determine liability for damages, but without receiving any power of attorney from the victims at this point. If the business operator is found liable in the first stage, the second stage begins, in which the consumer group is authorized to claim compensation on behalf of the victims and submits a report. During this phase, a process for confirming the existence and amount of individual victims’ claims is carried out.
Opt-in Model in Japan: Consumer Groups Lead the First Phase
Park Soyoung, Legislative Research Officer at the National Assembly Research Service (attorney-at-law), commented, “The Japanese system is a hybrid structure in which consumer associations play the leading role in the first stage, and affected individuals decide whether to participate in the second. If the consumer group loses in the first stage, the judgment does not apply to individual consumers, and only if they win do consumers have the option to participate in stage two. This is a strong consumer protection mechanism.”
The European Commission has recommended the opt-in method to its member states, warning about the risk of excessive and frivolous lawsuits under the opt-out approach. The Commission noted that the U.S.-style opt-out enables class actions even in the absence of legitimate grounds and may be abused as a tool to extract coercive settlements. It further pointed out that courts must clearly define the class in order to respect the rights of all parties, especially the defendant’s right of defense—a key reason for its support of the opt-in model.
Kang Youngki, Research Professor at Korea University Law Research Institute, argued, “In light of cases from Japan and Europe, the opt-in model is generally preferred over opt-out.” He explained, “The opt-in system is a safeguard to prevent individuals from having their legal rights decided without their knowledge. A limited opt-in model is better suited to the South Korean context.”
Kwon Jaeyeol, Professor at the Kyung Hee University School of Law, noted, “The right to litigate is, in a sense, also the right to refrain from litigation. The opt-out model, which could bring someone into a lawsuit without their knowledge, is problematic. In particular, companies can simultaneously face three different types of penalties for illegal behavior—criminal fines, administrative penalties, and civil damages. This triple financial liability inevitably places a significant burden on companies.”
Reflecting Korea’s Industrial Structure in Legal Design: Addressing the Risk of Frivolous Suits
Professor Kwon added that South Korea should factor its own industrial structure into the design of any new law. “Unlike the United States, Korea’s strength is in manufacturing. If companies are required to take on excessive liability due to the opt-out approach, it could have a serious impact on the growth of manufacturing industries. If class action legislation is to be introduced, it would be more appropriate to limit it to sectors that are especially sensitive to consumer harm, such as services and finance,” he suggested.
Choi Joonseon, Emeritus Professor at Sungkyunkwan University Law School, explained, "The opt-out approach infringes on personal autonomy, and it is something small companies will find difficult to bear."
There are also strong concerns within the legal community about retroactive application. The Ministry of Justice is reportedly considering making the law retroactively applicable to claims where damages occurred within three years prior to its effective date. Such retroactive application of class action judgments could violate the constitutional principle of the protection of trust, and thus could be problematic.
Professor Choi warned, "Class action law focuses primarily on consumer protection, but massive compensation payouts could inadvertently harm other stakeholders—such as employees, suppliers, creditors, bondholders, and small shareholders. Above all, retroactive application could worsen the financial situation of a company to the point of threatening its survival and push down share prices, which could harm minority shareholders. Furthermore, if retroactive application is allowed, it becomes possible for class action lawsuits to proceed on behalf of victims even when individual lawsuits have already resulted in final rulings or compensation, leading to contradictory judgments and unequal results among victims."
Choi Kyoungjin, Professor of Law at Gachon University, stated, “Retroactive application may trigger lawsuits related to unforeseen past events, and companies would be unable to anticipate the potential financial shock. This undermines constitutional values and could provoke social unrest.”
Professor Choi emphasized the need for a comprehensive redesign of class action legislation to suit domestic circumstances. "Adopting the opt-out model across all areas would have both positive and negative effects, but these outcomes have not been accurately predicted yet," he said. "If legislation is pushed forward rapidly without sound projections regarding its impact, there could be significant side effects." He continued, "Not only the structure of opt-out versus opt-in, but also the configuration of the other provisions will determine the overall design of the law. Who will bear litigation costs, whether the opt-out model will be truly effective, and whether it will result in an excessive burden on businesses—all of these issues require thorough review before enacting the law."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.