Supreme Court: "Refusal of Incineration Plant Violates Trust"
"Non-Conformity Ruling for Crushing and Shredding Facility is Lawful"

The Supreme Court has finalized a series of mixed rulings in a legal battle that lasted over five years between Cheongju City and a private company regarding the construction of a waste incineration plant in Hugi-ri, Ochang-eup, Cheongju, Chungbuk Province. The final judgment is that while it was illegal for Cheongju City to break the original Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) and refuse the proposal for the incineration plant, its notification of non-conformity regarding the plan for crushing and shredding facilities was lawful.

Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

The Supreme Court's Third Division (Presiding Justice Oh Seokjun) on the 13th affirmed the appellate court's partial ruling in favor of the plaintiff in the 'litigation to cancel the refusal of the urban management plan proposal' filed by Seowon Environment (formerly ESG Cheongwon) against the Mayor of Cheongju.


Seowon Environment, which had been promoting the installation of a landfill and incineration facility in Ochang Science Complex, faced opposition from local residents and in March 2015 signed a business agreement with Cheongju City in which the parties agreed to "actively cooperate in relocating incineration facilities and others to another area within the city." Afterward, aiming to relocate the facilities, Seowon Environment proposed in December 2020 to build a 165-ton per day incineration facility and a 160-ton per day crushing and shredding facility in Hugi-ri, Ochang-eup, and submitted a proposal for an urban management plan. However, Cheongju City rejected the proposal, citing adverse effects on the environment and residents' health.


The court of first instance sided with Cheongju City, stating that the city had discretion over urban planning decisions. However, the appellate court overturned this decision, ruling that "Cheongju City violated the principle of protection of legitimate expectations by promising relocation through the agreement and then refusing it later." The appellate court further found that the part relating to the crushing and shredding facility was not covered under the agreement and considered Cheongju City's rejection lawful for that portion.


The Supreme Court also agreed with the appellate court's decision and dismissed appeals from both sides.


Meanwhile, on the same day, the Supreme Court's Third Division (Presiding Justice Lee Heunggu) overturned the appellate court's ruling, which had found in favor of Seowon Environment in its 'litigation to cancel the notification of non-conformity for the waste disposal project plan' against Cheongju City, and remanded the case to the Seoul High Court.


Cheongju City initially found Seowon Environment's 2018 crushing and shredding facility project plan to be in conformity; however, after the permit period lapsed and the company resubmitted its project plan in March 2021, the city issued a non-conformity notification citing failure to meet urban planning facility decision criteria under the National Land Planning and Utilization Act.


Both the trial and the appellate court had deemed Cheongju City's action unlawful, arguing that the urban planning review was a subsequent procedure. However, the Supreme Court took a different position.



The Supreme Court determined that the 'violation of other laws,' which is the subject of review under the Wastes Control Act, also includes the regulations of the National Land Planning and Utilization Act. The court stated, "If the location and other details of waste facilities, which require an urban management plan decision, conflict with the standards of the National Land Planning and Utilization Act, Cheongju City may, even at the project plan stage, issue a non-conformity notification under the Wastes Control Act," thereby siding with Cheongju City.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing