Kim Buyeol's "Why We Help Poor Countries"

Questioning Aid Not as Sympathy, But as Investment

Poverty Has Fallen, But So Has Aid... The Real Issue: Who Do We Count as "Us"?

A family is starving. If you had 1 million won on hand, how much would you be willing to give away? In "Why We Help Poor Countries," Kim Buyeol asks whether it is really so hard to give up 7,000 won. That is just 0.7% of 1 million won—the same proportion that the international community has long set as its target for Official Development Assistance (ODA) from developed countries: 0.7% of Gross National Income (GNI). Yet the reality tells a different story. Last year, member countries of the Development Assistance Committee in the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) decreased their ODA by 23.1%, the sharpest decline since records began. In 2025, Korea's ODA will amount to 0.2% of its GNI—the equivalent of 2,000 won out of 1 million won.

[How About This Book] 7,000 Won Out of 1 Million: A World That Hesitates to Give View original image

The author, a professor at the Graduate School of Environmental Studies at Seoul National University, is not a scholar who has studied poverty only from behind a desk. He has participated in projects supporting girls' education, AIDS prevention, and maternal and child health in Malawi, Ethiopia, and Ghana, as well as conducted field research in rural areas of Myanmar and Cambodia. As such, the phrase "help them because they are poor" rarely appears in this book. Instead, the author asks what has been invested, what has changed, and why some policies failed. From the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) to the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), from market failure and government failure to social enterprises and impact measurement, the book places good intentions under the scrutiny of economics.


Numbers once permitted optimism. As the book points out, the global extreme poverty rate fell from the high 30% range in the 1990s to around 8.5% in 2019. However, if this is read solely as a victory for aid, the story becomes overly simple. The World Bank highlights the widespread economic growth of East Asia and South Asia as a major driving force for long-term poverty reduction. The interplay of aid, economic growth, trade, and national capacity produced these results. This complexity, in fact, makes the book's questions even harder. The reality that aid cannot solve everything raises a paradox: does that mean there is no need to help at all?


One of his studies offers a small answer. In a randomized controlled trial (RCT) involving 3,997 female students at 33 public secondary schools in Malawi, students who received tuition and cash support for a year attended classes more regularly and had higher test scores and educational expectations. A single scholarship cannot end poverty. Yet it can keep a girl from dropping out of school. It is in moments like this that the grand term "international development" connects to real lives. Statistics can sometimes erase individuals, but when used well, they can prove which policies have saved lives.

A teacher certified by the Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) established by Korea is teaching automotive maintenance skills to students in Rwanda. KOICA

A teacher certified by the Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) established by Korea is teaching automotive maintenance skills to students in Rwanda. KOICA

View original image

The problem is that even after seeing this evidence, the world is still closing its wallet. The United Nations "Sustainable Development Goals Report 2026" forecasts the global extreme poverty rate to be 10% this year. Effectively, eradicating extreme poverty by 2030 is now out of reach. The OECD reports that in 2025, aid for the poorest countries has declined by 25.8%, and support for Sub-Saharan Africa by 26.3%. This year’s ODA is also expected to decrease further. Just after the world saw, through COVID-19, war, and the climate crisis, how deeply interconnected everything is, countries have shifted back to prioritizing their own citizens. At this point, "Why Help Poor Countries" becomes not a textbook question, but a political one.


The book concludes that neither the government nor the market alone is enough, and seeks new possibilities in social enterprises, social ventures, and social finance. It presents examples of turning social value into sustainable economic activity, such as Muhammad Yunus’s microcredit initiatives, Patagonia, and the Social Progress Incentive program by SK Group. These are pragmatic suggestions—and also the most contentious ones. To overcome poverty, goodwill has to persist, but for that to happen, the logic of money must also come into play. Yet the moment social value is converted into figures, another question arises: Who will save those whose lives and achievements are hard to quantify? This is why the book asks about the "statistical value of life."


That is why the “reason” in the book’s title is never fully closed, even in its final pages. Helping poor countries is neither sentimental charity nor a calculated investment whose math is finished. Sometimes it fails, is wasted, or doesn't change the world as much as we hope. Yet, when we hesitate to give 7,000 won out of 1 million, something deeper is revealed. Perhaps what we are really calculating is not the amount of money, but who we consider part of "us." What this book ultimately seeks to expand is not the aid budget, but that boundary.



Why We Help Poor Countries | Written by Kim Buyeol | 21st Century Books | 232 pages


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing