[SCMP Column] US Locks Out Chinese Robots...More About Holding Back Than Protecting Its Own Industry
There is a certain formula to a concession speech: declaring an unwillingness to surrender, thanking supporters, and pledging to continue the fight. Last month, Brendan Carr, Commissioner of the U.S. Federal Communications Commission (FCC), effectively gave such a 'concession speech' on behalf of the American robotics industry.
Based on the findings of a White House task force, Commissioner Carr added newly manufactured humanoid robots, quadruped robots, and power inverters produced overseas to the FCC’s "Covered List." Being put on this list means it is impossible to obtain the FCC approval needed to sell most electronic devices in the U.S. The FCC cited cybersecurity and supply chain risks as justification for the regulation.
However, the overwhelming market gap forms an unspoken backdrop to this decision. Chinese firms occupy about 85% of the global humanoid robotics market. In the U.S., there is not yet a well-established industry in this sector that is worth protecting, and only early-stage industries exist that require high barriers to entry for nurturing.
The industry has interpreted this measure as a signal that the U.S. intends to protect and foster its robotics sector. Evan Beard, CEO of Standard Bots, called it one of the strongest technology security moves in modern American history. He also emphasized that, with the backing of foreign government subsidies, robots would not be allowed to "dominate the U.S. robotics market as happened in the solar industry."
The security concerns themselves have merit. Robots equipped with cameras, microphones, limbs, and connected to networks, if deployed in factories or care homes, could be used for espionage or even destructive activities.
However, this move raises questions about how seriously the U.S. government takes the very threats it has identified. While these robots are deemed dangerous to the general public, the federal government has allowed itself an exemption to keep buying them. If the threat does not apply to the government, then the primary purpose is less about 'security,' and more a trade barrier cloaked in the logic of security.
Here, it is worth revisiting the example of the solar industry cited by Beard. Since 2012, under the Obama administration, the U.S. has imposed anti-dumping tariffs to limit the entry of Chinese solar panels into the domestic market. Nevertheless, China now holds over 80% of the global market share in every stage of solar panel manufacturing. Trade barriers succeeded in blocking Chinese firms from the U.S. market—but did nothing to alter the global industrial leadership.
This does not mean the U.S. has failed to benefit from protectionism. China has proven over the past two decades that it can grow industrial competitiveness through protection and nurturing policies. It has built a leading electric vehicle industry through mandatory local joint ventures for foreign companies and substantial government subsidies.
However, China’s industrial protection policies came with intense competition. Dozens of domestic automakers faced fierce price wars, making survival far from guaranteed; only those who survived tested their competitiveness in overseas markets. In China’s approach, protection is not a permanent shield but more a training period to build competitiveness.
In the 20th century, the success of protectionist policies varied. Latin American countries implemented import substitution and kept their markets closed, but their industries stagnated for decades. In contrast, Japan and Korea linked government support to export performance, pushing companies into international competition and nurturing global giants such as Toyota and Samsung. The model chosen by the FCC aligns more closely with the Latin American approach. While American companies remain sheltered within a protected domestic market, Chinese robots could become the de facto global standard.
Chinese robotic products are already rapidly proliferating in the global market. Europe, suffering from labor shortages, still lacks a humanoid robotics manufacturer with mass production capabilities. European buyers have little reason to wait for American companies to catch up; they will likely select what is available now. Overwhelmingly, the humanoid robots available on the market are Chinese-made. The more actual deployments there are, the more humanoids improve in performance, leveraging data gathered in warehouses and other environments to refine future models.
Most concession speeches end in a similar fashion: the cause continues, and the speaker promises to begin the fight anew tomorrow. The American robotics industry still has its opportunities. U.S. manufacturing has successfully recovered in the past, and with the humanoid robot market currently worth about $3 billion and expected to grow to $200 billion by 2035, there is still plenty of time for the competitive landscape to shift.
But when Chinese President Xi Jinping visits the United States next month, he will encounter a U.S. that, under the banner of preparing for future competition, has essentially surrendered present leadership to China. In the meantime, Chinese robots are being deployed into factories and warehouses around the world, and they are likely to reach care facilities before long.
Regardless, the FCC still calls this a matter of national security. China calls it bullying. Yet history is likely to record this as a 'concession' in which the U.S. handed the present to China.
Thomas O. Polk, SCMP Columnist
This article is a translation of the South China Morning Post (SCMP) column 'US does its robotics industry no favours by fencing it off from China' by The Asia Business Daily.
※This column is published as part of a strategic partnership between The Asia Business Daily and the South China Morning Post.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.