"No Legal Status Justifying Occupation"

The Supreme Court has ruled that the Seoul Metropolitan Government must pay 42.1 billion won in compensation after losing a lawsuit against the Korea National Railway concerning the usage fees for the Gyeongui Line Forest Trail site.

Seoul Mapo-gu Gyeongui Line Forest Trail. Photo by Jin-Hyung Kang aymsdream@

Seoul Mapo-gu Gyeongui Line Forest Trail. Photo by Jin-Hyung Kang aymsdream@

View original image

The Supreme Court’s Division 2 (Presiding Justice Eom Sang-pil) on August 12 upheld the lower court ruling against Seoul in the final appeal of the lawsuit filed by the city against the Korea National Railway to cancel the penalty imposition.


This dispute began with an agreement between Seoul and the corporation in December 2010. At that time, both parties agreed that, in exchange for creating a park on a 99,736.4 square meter stretch of above-ground land between Yongsan Cultural Center and Gajwa Station, Seoul would cooperate with the corporation’s station area development projects. Based on this, the corporation allowed Seoul to use the land free of charge for five years starting in July 2011 and granted an additional year of free use in 2016, while Seoul created and operated the park.


However, conflict arose in May 2017 when the corporation notified the city that the period of free use had expired and they would transition to a paid arrangement. Citing the Enforcement Decree of the State Property Act, which limits the free-use period of state property for local governments, the corporation imposed a penalty of approximately 42,120,150,000 won. Seoul, disagreeing with this, filed a lawsuit in February 2021.


The lower courts were divided. The court of first instance acknowledged the binding force of the agreement, ruling in favor of Seoul by stating that the city retained the right of free use as long as the park existed. However, the appellate court overturned this, ruling that Seoul did not have the right to occupy and use the Gyeongui Line Forest Trail site free of charge, and found the corporation's penalty imposition to be lawful.


The Supreme Court sided with the appellate court. The justices stated, "Seoul cannot be considered to possess the legal right to occupy or use the site free of charge, nor does it have a legal status to justify such occupation based on the agreement or other grounds, as long as the park remains."



They added, "The corporation’s imposition of the penalty does not violate the principle of protection of trust or proportionality, and the provision in the Enforcement Decree of the State Property Act that limits the free-use exemption for local governments to one year also does not violate the principle of statutory reservation nor exceed the scope of delegation by the main law."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing