[Inside Chodong] The Pitfalls of Infallibility and the President's Choice View original image

During President Lee Jae-myung's New Year's press conference this past January, a reporter drew attention to the steep rise of the KOSPI. The index had surpassed the 4,900 mark and was approaching 5,000, but the gains were concentrated in a few sectors such as semiconductors. The reporter pointed out that, due to this polarization, there were concerns that the market fundamentals of the overall economy had not meaningfully improved, raising fears of a sudden plunge.


President Lee challenged the initial premise. He remarked, “It seems somewhat logically inconsistent,” and added, “If most stocks are not rising, then there’s no risk of them dropping either.” Although he admitted that the market concentration was problematic, he dismissed the concerns, saying, “There are reasons why certain stocks go up and reasons why others go down, so the market does not swing wildly at will.”


For a while, it seemed that President Lee’s answer was proving true. On June 18, the KOSPI surpassed the 9,000 mark for the first time, recording an all-time closing high of 9,114 on the 22nd. The excitement was short-lived. The market began to decline, led by semiconductor stocks. Eventually, on July 28, the KOSPI fell 10%, and on the 29th, it dropped another 6%, briefly plunging to 5,262 during trading. For the first time ever, circuit breakers were triggered on both the KOSPI and KOSDAQ for two consecutive days.


Samsung Electronics and SK hynix, which had led the rally, ended up deepening the index’s drop. The concern that President Lee called a “logical inconsistency” had become reality. In particular, single-stock leveraged exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that track the daily returns of these two stocks at twice the rate came under scrutiny. Launched on May 27, these products saw individual investors’ net purchases reach approximately 8.2 trillion won by June 19. Although setbacks such as the forced liquidation of high-performing US AI hedge funds and a global correction in semiconductor stocks also played a part, the products were heavily criticized for amplifying volatility to irrational levels—a criticism that persists today. Among investors who switched from US to Korean stocks, some are now recalling the saying: “This is why, in the end, US stocks are the answer.”


An unanswered question remains: “Why did it happen at that particular time?” The main rationale for introducing leveraged ETFs was to broaden investor choice and attract “Seohak ants”—Korean investors in overseas assets—back to the domestic market, thereby stabilizing the exchange rate. High exchange rates had been a complex challenge since the beginning of the administration. However, the problem was that 18 leveraged products (including both ETFs and exchange-traded notes) were listed all at once, precisely when market concentration in specific stocks intensified and the index soared. In hindsight, the authorities may have been aware of the risk: Lee Chanjin, governor of the Financial Supervisory Service, later admitted, “Perhaps we should have stopped it at all costs, even if it meant lying down in protest.”


Recently, a former senior financial official I met in private commented, “It seems that some impurities found their way into the process of policy decision-making and implementation.” According to this view, the optimal timing was missed because political calculations took precedence over sound policy judgment, and pushed by certain forces, the government failed to avoid the worst timing altogether. There may also have been the longstanding inertia of the bureaucracy, which tends to look only to the President and the Blue House for direction.



In its second year, the Lee Jae-myung administration faces a host of challenges, including normalization of the real estate and capital markets, addressing the aftermath of the K-shaped polarization, and launching institutions such as the Prosecution Agency and the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency. These are issues where hesitation or distortion in choosing the right moment can trigger a strong backlash. Decisions are considered “infallible” only because they are final, but the judgment and choices of the ultimate decision maker are not always correct. That is the wisdom President Lee and his advisors at the Blue House need now.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing