"Recognized as Justifiable Conduct"

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul.

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul.

View original image

The Supreme Court has overturned a lower court ruling that convicted a niece who confronted her uncle with a weapon in a standoff, after he allegedly assaulted her at her home and threatened her with scissors because she had exposed his sexual harassment.


According to the legal community on August 12, the first division of the Supreme Court (Presiding Justice Cheon Dae-yeop) recently overturned the lower court’s decision to give a suspended fine to a woman in her 40s, identified as A, who had been indicted on charges of making special threats. The case was sent back to the Incheon District Court with the intent for acquittal.


The case began when A revealed to her family that she had been sexually harassed as a child by her uncle, B (male, 76). Enraged by this, in 2022, B went to A’s home and assaulted her as she returned from work, punching her and starting a physical altercation. During the fight, B picked up a pair of scissors that were on the dining table and threatened A, saying, "I have lived long enough. If I kill you and die myself, it will be fine."


In response, A grabbed a kitchen knife from the sink and said, "If you want to die, die yourself. If you want to die, then come here," leading to a standoff. As a result, she was put on trial on charges of making special threats.


The key issue was whether A’s actions in bringing out a weapon constituted a justifiable act. Both the first and second trial courts found that A’s actions did not meet the requirements for self-defense and convicted her. In the appellate decision, the court noted that even after B put the scissors down, A continued to hold the weapon, and stated, "Given that the degree of physical force exerted by B does not seem to have suppressed A’s freedom of movement, it is difficult to acknowledge the proportionality of A’s chosen means or methods." The court sentenced her to a 3 million won fine with a one-year suspension.



The Supreme Court did not accept this reasoning. The justices stated, "The defendant’s actions were a passive and defensive response to the victim’s continued unjust attack, in which he arrived without warning, used violence, and threatened to inflict harm on her life and body with scissors." They added, "Considering that A herself called 112, and that there were no further acts of threat until the police arrived, there is ample room to evaluate her conduct as justifiable and not in violation of social norms."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing