Citizens Trapped by Algorithms and Public Broadcasting That Has Lost Trust
Solving the Crisis With "Public Interest Algorithms" and the "Platform Beacon"

Two years ago, during the period of martial law, the special broadcast viewership rating of Korean Broadcasting System (KBS) was dismal. At just 3.2%, it was less than half that of Munhwa Broadcasting Corporation (MBC), which recorded 6.8%. Even in the face of a national crisis, citizens did not turn to "public broadcasting." The content itself was also problematic. Under the pretext of maintaining neutrality, the coverage focused on explaining the reasons for the martial law and conveying differences between the positions of the ruling and opposition parties.


Kim Jongmyung, author of the newly published book "Electronic Cave - Can We Become Reconnected?", criticizes public broadcasting for losing the trust of its citizens. The author joined KBS as part of the "first cohort of democratic recruitment" right after the democratization movement in 1987. He assesses the history of his organization as a process of gradually undermining its own trust. With every change in administration, parachuting of personnel and interference in the newsroom have repeatedly occurred, coupled with power struggles between multiple labor unions. While internal conflicts consumed the organization, citizens began turning to new platforms such as YouTube and social networking services (SNS).


Alongside the crisis in public broadcasting, viewers themselves have found themselves at risk of not receiving reliable information. Smartphones and AI algorithms have begun to enclose individuals in personalized information environments, locking them into their own tastes and confirmation biases. The author explains this phenomenon through the concept of the "Electronic Cave." This concept adapts Plato's "Cave" allegory and American journalist Walter Lippmann's idea of the "pseudo-environment" (a subjective, fabricated reality created by mass media and stereotypes) for the AI era. Just as the people inside Plato's cave believed the shadows on the wall were real, we now see reality curated by smartphones and algorithms. Platforms repeatedly serve users content tailored to their preferences, anger, and fears. As a result, people become increasingly convinced of their own beliefs, unaware they are trapped in a bubble of bias.


To overcome the crises facing public broadcasting and its viewers, the author argues for a renewed role for public broadcasting, centered on a "public interest algorithm" and a "platform beacon." The "public interest algorithm" is a proposal to embed factors of public interest, diversity, locality, and trustworthiness into the recommendation systems of commercial platforms such as YouTube. The goal is to design serendipitous encounters with essential policies and information on local issues, disasters, and safety—content users must know, even if they do not actively seek it out themselves.


The "platform beacon" refers to the infrastructure required for the production of credible content to support this objective. This involves creating a "fact-checking hub" based on public data, with participation from both experts and citizens, and distributing verified information through the public interest algorithm. AI can be used for data collection and analysis, but humans must assume final decision-making and the responsibility of explaining conclusions. The idea is to establish a so-called "triangle of trust," connecting data, algorithms, and human accountability.


As a leading example of public broadcasting harmonizing with new platforms, the author introduces Mark Thompson, the CEO of CNN. During his time at the BBC, Thompson's strategic partnership with YouTube marked a turning point in media history. Rather than simply repackaging existing content for new platforms, the focus was on designing and producing content specifically for platform-driven environments from inception. He subsequently led The New York Times' paid subscription model to success and continues to experiment at CNN. The key point is that, instead of demanding citizens "come to our channel," the media proactively reached out to citizens where they were.


However, one question remains. What exactly qualifies as public interest information, and who sets these standards? If national governments or public media organizations become involved in influencing algorithms, it could become surveillance and interference disguised as public interest. Moreover, many private experts today already produce content that is more in-depth and specialized than public media. The scope and operational details of the "platform beacon" concept, as described by the author, require further clarification.



Electronic Cave - Can We Become Reconnected? | Written by Kim Jongmyung | Paper Road

[Bbang-Gubneun Tajaegi]A National Crisis Struck... But People Turned Off Their TVs View original image


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing