Even with Increased Foot Traffic, Fashion Malls Remain "Empty"

Macstyle, Dongdaemun’s Retail and Wholesale Mall, Sees 99% Vacancy Rate

Conversion Hindered by Complex Split-Ownership Structure

On the afternoon of August 10 in Macstyle, Jung-gu, Seoul, the once-bustling commercial building, which used to be crowded with shoppers and wholesalers, was eerily quiet. The stores lined up on both sides of the corridor had their lights off and shutters down. There was no electricity. In front of closed stores, various fixtures and display stands were scattered around. Throughout the building, there were large posters not for customers, but announcing conflicts between the management council and the property management corporation.


Nearby at Milliore, except for imported clothing stores on the lower floors, the atmosphere was also subdued. On the fifth floor, where watch and accessories shops are clustered, less than one third of the stores remained open for business. Even though many stores are closely packed together, there were more merchants than customers on site. “Since the COVID-19 pandemic, the drop in customer numbers has never recovered,” said Mr. Lee (42), who has been selling clothes around Dongdaemun for over 10 years.


On the 10th, stalls were scattered across the first-floor shopping area of Macstyle in Jung-gu, Seoul. The stores where merchants used to sell clothing and other items are now being used like warehouses. Photo by Ji-Eun Oh

On the 10th, stalls were scattered across the first-floor shopping area of Macstyle in Jung-gu, Seoul. The stores where merchants used to sell clothing and other items are now being used like warehouses. Photo by Ji-Eun Oh

View original image

The Dongdaemun commercial district in Seoul, once considered a mecca of fashion, has been unable to escape a prolonged slump. While foot traffic has increased, the business district itself has continued to shrink due to shifts in consumption patterns, such as the rise of online shopping. Additionally, the unique issue of collective ownership—where each store has a different owner—makes it difficult to reorganize the area.


According to the Seoul Design Foundation on August 11, the Dongdaemun Design Plaza (DDP) attracted 13.73 million visitors in 2023, 17.29 million in 2024, and 17.12 million last year. Since opening in 2014, DDP has become a key landmark in Dongdaemun and a central hub connecting nearby fashion and tourism districts. In 2018, the number of visitors exceeded 10 million for the first time, but it fell to 6.72 million in 2020 due to the impact of COVID-19. Since then, the area has more than recovered, establishing itself as a leading tourist destination.


However, the influx of visitors to DDP has not translated into increased sales or vitality for nearby fashion shopping centers. According to the Dongdaemun Fashion Town Tourism Special Zone Council, vacancy rates for major malls stood at 85% for Goodmorning City, 58% for Hello APM, and 39% for Milliore as of last month. Notably, Macstyle, which had been the only combined retail and wholesale shopping mall in Dongdaemun, saw its vacancy rate reach nearly 99%. Of 2,654 stores in the building, just over 30 are still open for business.

More Visitors to Dongdaemun, But the Business District Remains Empty View original image

Since the late 1990s, Dongdaemun grew into Korea’s largest fashion shopping destination with the opening of numerous large malls. The synergy of late-night wholesale markets and enormous shopping centers attracted not just Korean consumers, but also tourists from China, Japan, and elsewhere. However, as mobile shopping rapidly spread and face-to-face transactions became less common during the COVID-19 era, demand for offline shopping plummeted. As a result, the downturn in the business district intensified significantly.


Even though the number of visitors and tourists, particularly around DDP, has rebounded, the fashion sector that once supported Dongdaemun still struggles to recover. Experts point to the large shopping malls' complicated ownership and management structures as the main cause. When each store in the area has a different owner within one building—a system called “split ownership”—it makes revitalizing the business district extremely difficult.


With hundreds or even thousands of owners in a single building, remodeling the entire property as a unified space demands a complex decision-making process. According to the Act on Ownership and Management of Aggregate Buildings, changes to communal areas require approval from more than two thirds of both the collective owners and total voting rights. Because of this, it is difficult even to convert these malls into offices, hotels, or cultural facilities to meet new market demands.


On the 10th, a rental notice was posted on the 5th floor, where watch and accessory stores are concentrated, in the Milliore shopping building in Jung-gu, Seoul. Photo by Ji-eun Oh

On the 10th, a rental notice was posted on the 5th floor, where watch and accessory stores are concentrated, in the Milliore shopping building in Jung-gu, Seoul. Photo by Ji-eun Oh

View original image

The structural limitations of buildings like Macstyle have even resulted in legal disputes. The management council (owners) and the property management corporation have been engaged in lawsuits over responsibility for management crises. As this conflict dragged on for over a decade, the combination of the economic downturn and worsening business conditions pushed the building's debt into the billions of won. Delays in payments for utilities such as water and electricity amounted to some 500 million won, resulting in a power cutoff since April this year and now posing the threat of a water cutoff. Merchants explained that they are barely surviving thanks to advertising revenue from the electronic display board on the building’s exterior and rental income from officetel units on the upper floors (9th to 18th).


An official at the Dongdaemun Fashion Town Tourism Special Zone Council commented, "Consumption behaviors among domestic consumers and tourists have changed drastically, so we can’t expect the same level of competitiveness just from fashion shopping. Reorienting the district, such as by introducing a variety of new business types through a change of use, is essential to transform Dongdaemun's entire business ecosystem."



Experts have also emphasized the urgent need for merchants to adapt. Seo Jinhyung, Professor of Real Estate and Law at Kwangwoon University, noted, "Dongdaemun's prolonged slump is not just due to a poor economy but results from both shifts in consumption patterns and the structural problem of collective ownership. Revamping the area will require legal reforms to allow for integrated building use, along with efforts by merchants themselves to introduce new experiences and other fresh content."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing