UK Study Analyzes Electric Scooter Accident Data
Risk of Brain Injury Estimated at 3.5 Times That of Motorcycles
Small Wheels and High Center of Gravity Increase Injury Severity

Analysis has found that electric scooter accidents pose a higher risk of serious injury to the head and internal organs compared to motorcycle or bicycle accidents.


Image of an electric scooter to aid in understanding the article. Pixabay

Image of an electric scooter to aid in understanding the article. Pixabay

View original image

According to Yonhap News on August 7, a research team led by orthopedic specialist David Bodansky at Chelsea and Westminster Hospital in the UK published these findings in the scientific journal Scientific Reports. The team stressed the urgent need for mandatory helmet use and improvements in device design.


The research focused on two separate datasets. The first involved 15,247 patients recorded in the England and Wales national severe trauma registry between 2020 and 2022. Of these, 580 were electric scooter users, 7,027 were motorcycle riders, and 7,640 were cyclists. The second dataset consisted of accident records reported by shared electric scooter companies operating in 18 UK cities from 2020 to 2024, covering over 33 million rides and more than 77.8 million kilometers traveled. The research team analyzed the two datasets independently, investigating a total of 38,440 cases.


Existing studies have generally relied on emergency room or trauma center reports, which has limited understanding of the overall injury landscape. In contrast, this analysis examined not only severe trauma cases requiring hospitalization but also minor collisions involving shared electric scooters.


The results showed that adult electric scooter users faced a 3.45 times higher risk of traumatic brain injury, a 3.24 times higher risk of vascular injury, and a 1.46 times higher risk of internal organ injury compared to motorcycle riders. The risk of traumatic brain injury was also 1.74 times higher than for cyclists. Some results were reversed for other categories: the risk of fractures was 20% lower compared to motorcycle riders and 10% lower compared to cyclists. This means that electric scooter accidents are more likely to result in brain and organ injuries rather than broken bones. In fact, traumatic brain injuries accounted for more than one third of injuries among adult electric scooter users.


Helmet Usage Rate Only 5.9%... Small Wheels, High Center of Gravity


Shared electric scooters placed on a street in Berlin, Germany. Photo by Reuters-Yonhap News.

Shared electric scooters placed on a street in Berlin, Germany. Photo by Reuters-Yonhap News.

View original image

The research team identified two main causes. The first is helmet use. According to the registry, 75.7% of motorcycle riders and 45.0% of cyclists wore helmets, while only 5.9% of electric scooter users did so. The second factor is the device structure: electric scooters often have small wheels and lack suspension, which makes them prone to tipping over when hitting curbs, potholes, or uneven surfaces. Standing while riding raises and shifts the center of gravity forward, increasing the likelihood that the rider will fall headfirst over the handlebars in a crash.


The research also found that certain groups, including teenagers and women, face notably higher risks. Among electric scooter injury cases, people under 18 accounted for 16.2%, compared to 6.2% for motorcycle riders and 8.9% for cyclists. This age group also showed a significant proportion of craniofacial injuries. Female electric scooter users were 2.1 times more likely to sustain serious injuries than their male counterparts. There were also regional disparities: after adjusting for distance traveled, collision rates varied depending on the socioeconomic conditions of each area, with more disadvantaged areas experiencing higher accident rates.


The study's authors emphasized, "Mandatory helmet use, stricter speed limits, improvements such as shock-absorbing handlebars and brake systems, and expansion of safe riding infrastructure must all be promoted together." They further noted, "Policies need to address the socio-demographic factors that influence the safety of electric scooter use."


In the UK, Privately-Owned Rides Are Illegal, While Korea Requires Licenses


In the UK, the government currently allows shared electric scooter rentals only in pilot locations such as Liverpool, Bristol, Birmingham, and certain London boroughs. In contrast, it remains illegal for individuals to ride privately owned electric scooters in public areas.



In Korea, electric scooters are regulated as "personal mobility devices" under the Road Traffic Act. Their maximum speed is limited to 25 km/h, and users must have at least a moped license, making riders under 16 ineligible. Wearing a helmet and riding with more than one person on a scooter are both mandatory. The National Assembly has also discussed bills to require rental operators to verify users’ ages and confirm completion of safety training courses.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing