In 2020, 59.9 Billion Won in Citizen Proposals Was Funded
Number of Citizen Proposals in Seoul Drops, Most Deemed 'Ineligible'
"A Missed Opportunity to Engage in Grassroots Democracy"

There are growing criticisms that Seoul City's participatory budgeting system has effectively become a “nominal system” in name only. Contrary to its original aim—to increase public engagement in policymaking by reflecting citizen-proposed projects in the city's budget—the actual amount allocated has dwindled to just 4% of what it was a decade ago.

'A Nominal Participatory Budgeting System'... Seoul's Budget Shrinks from 50 Billion to 1.9 Billion Won in 10 Years View original image

According to Seoul City on August 7, citizens submitted a total of 614 project proposals last year, with requested funding amounting to 267.8 billion won. However, after review by the relevant departments and deliberation by the Seoul Metropolitan Council, only 13 projects were incorporated into this year’s budget, and the total allocation was just 1.9 billion won.


This represents a dramatic decrease compared to ten years ago when the same system was in place. At that time, there were 3,593 citizen-submitted proposals (worth 465.2 billion won), and 510 of those projects (amounting to 48.7 billion won) were included in the 2016 budget. In 2020, the total allocated under the participatory budgeting system even reached a record high of 59.9 billion won since the program’s inception. However, following Mayor Oh Se-hoon's inauguration, not only did the number of proposals decrease, but the budget allocated to them plummeted. The budget allocated for this year is now only about 4% of what it was ten years ago.


Each year, Seoul City accepts citizen proposals online and offline for about 50 days starting in March. The main topics usually include improvement of daily inconveniences, support for vulnerable groups, solutions to youth issues, and future-oriented projects. However, last year, 589 out of 614 proposals were deemed ineligible due to concerns about feasibility or redundancy. As a result, only 13 projects (with a combined budget of 1.9 billion won) were submitted to the city council, and all of them were included in this year's budget.


Perhaps recognizing concerns over the system’s effectiveness, Seoul City announced an “Operational Plan for Participatory Budgeting” this past February, indicating it would seek improvements. “We need to establish a system that incentivizes citizens to participate voluntarily and review ways to enhance awareness of the program,” city officials explained. Nevertheless, as the budget continues to shrink, it seems inevitable that criticisms will persist that the participatory budgeting system has lost its original intent and is being maintained in name only.



Choi Hyunseon, a professor in the Department of Public Administration at Myongji University, stated, “Allowing citizens to directly propose solutions to daily inconveniences and participate in the budget-setting process is a crucial step in fostering grassroots democracy. If opportunities for participation diminish, the chance for citizens to practice and learn democracy is lost.” He added, “Even 50 billion won is just 0.1% of Seoul City’s 50 trillion won annual budget, which is hardly a burden for the city finances. It is regrettable that such drastic budget cuts have seemingly closed off channels for citizens to make their voices heard.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing