‘Surcharge on Major Shareholders’ Rises from 20 Billion to Hundreds of Billions… Why Joo Byung-Ki’s FTC Changed Its Approach [Why&Next]
Basis for Surcharge: Greater of Omitted Affiliates’ Assets or Revenue
Introduction of Surcharge Imposed Directly on Major Shareholder
Reflects Determination for Strict Action Against Conglomerate Wrongdoing
One of the most notable aspects of the Fair Trade Commission's presidential work report for the second half of the year is the introduction of the so-called "owner surcharge." Under this plan, if a conglomerate omits affiliates when submitting designation data, a surcharge of up to 10% of either the total assets or the combined average annual revenue of the omitted affiliates—whichever amount is greater—will be imposed on the owner personally. The Fair Trade Commission plans to pursue legislative amendments in the second half of the year to introduce the system.
Introduction of a 10% Surcharge Rate... Reflecting the Determination for "Strong Punishment"
Joo Byung-ki, Chairman of the Korea Fair Trade Commission, is reporting on the key plans for the second half of the year, including the establishment of a new surtax for conglomerate owners, during a presidential briefing held at the Blue House State Banquet Hall on the 4th. Photo by Yonhap News.
View original imageAccording to the Fair Trade Commission on August 10, this is the first time that the introduction of a "fixed-percentage surcharge" for individual conglomerate owners has been officially announced in a work report. Previously, Chairman Joo Byunggi had stated at a press briefing in May that the commission was considering a new "fixed-amount surcharge" with an upper limit of 20 billion won for false submissions of designation data. After three months of internal review, the commission developed the fixed-percentage surcharge approach and concrete criteria for its imposition. A commission official explained, "For acts where it is difficult to quantify the scale of the false reporting of designation data, a fixed-amount surcharge will be imposed. In cases of omitted affiliates, a fixed-percentage surcharge proportional to the violation will be imposed on the owner. This is a further specification of the original plan."
Designation data refers to information that the Fair Trade Commission annually collects from conglomerate owners to designate business groups—it includes details on affiliates, relatives, executives, and shareholders, and serves as a foundation for business group policy. However, under current fair trade law, penalties for false reporting or omissions are limited to imprisonment of up to two years or a fine of up to 15 million won, prompting ongoing criticism over their lack of effectiveness.
Insiders and outsiders at the Fair Trade Commission say this measure reflects Chairman Joo's determination to respond strictly to unfair practices by large business groups. A legal expert noted, "Chairman Joo has consistently raised the need for strong sanctions against false reporting of designation data at academic conferences and seminars. The creation of the fixed-percentage surcharge system can be seen as the institutionalization of this awareness of the issue."
In fact, during the three years of the Yoon Suk-yeol administration, only one conglomerate owner was prosecuted for submitting false designation data to the prosecution. However, since Chairman Joo took office, the heads of HDC Group, DB Group, and Youngone Group have each been reported to the prosecution. More recently, guidelines have been tightened to require that, as a general rule, owners with a record of submitting false data in the last three years and who have already received a warning are to be reported as well.
'Whichever Is Greater: Assets or Revenue'... Blocking Corporate Loopholes
It is also noteworthy that the standard for the owner surcharge will be whichever is greater—total assets or revenue. This is distinct from the commission's current system, which primarily relies on revenue. The intention is to prevent conglomerate owners from intentionally omitting affiliates that have significant assets, such as real estate or stocks but little revenue, in order to avoid being designated as a large business group. A commission official explained, "Even if an affiliate generates little revenue, omitting a company with assets worth hundreds of billions of won could allow an owner to evade designation as a Publicly Designated Business Group (assets of 5 trillion won or more) or a Business Group Subject to Restrictions on Mutual Investment (assets of 10 trillion won or more). Considering the seriousness and potential benefit of such a violation, it is only reasonable to set the basis as whichever is greater—assets or revenue."
If applied to cases prosecuted by the commission this year, the owner surcharge could reach several hundred billion won. For example, in the case of Youngone Group Chairman Sung Kihak, who was prosecuted for omitting 82 affiliates to avoid designation as a Publicly Designated Business Group, the combined assets of the omitted affiliates amounted to 3.24 trillion won. Applying the 10% rule, the surcharge would be 324 billion won. Likewise, from 2021 to 2024, HDC Group Chairman Chung Mong-gyu omitted 20 family-affiliate companies, whose annual combined assets ranged from 1 trillion won to 1.2 trillion won. Applying the same rule would mean a surcharge of up to 120 billion won. However, as both cases occurred in the past, the upcoming owner surcharge system will not retroactively apply to them.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
The business community is closely watching the potential impact. An executive at a major company said, "Sanctions that impose a direct financial burden on the owner personally are the most sensitive measures for companies. They are effectively the strongest warning, designed to ensure compliance. Going forward, companies will have to pay far more attention during the verification and submission of affiliate designation data than they have so far."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.