Involvement of Prosecutors With Around 10 Years' Experience Is Essential
Mismatch Between SCIA and Prosecution Rank Structure
Briefings Fail to Address Key Questions
"Everything Is Still Under Discussion" -- Lack of Information Cited
C

"Prosecutors Facing Bottleneck and Identity Dilemma in Moving to SCIA" View original image
"Prosecutors Facing Bottleneck and Identity Dilemma in Moving to SCIA" View original image

The Serious Crime Investigation Agency (SCIA), which is scheduled to launch on October 2, is struggling from the outset with the crucial issue of securing personnel. For a smooth transition, it is essential that mid-career prosecutors with around 10 years of frontline investigation experience join the agency. However, within the prosecution service, there is reluctance to transfer to the SCIA due to concerns about demotion in rank and the label of being recategorized as an investigator. While a large-scale transfer is unlikely, it is expected that some experienced prosecutors or senior officials on the verge of retirement may apply to the SCIA as a way to enhance their resume and be branded as the so-called "First Penguins"—the pioneers of the agency.


The government has offered incentives as well. Prosecutors who wish to transfer can be appointed as investigators at the SCIA without taking an additional exam, as long as they apply by April 30 next year. Under a temporary special provision during this period, they will also retain the compensation they received as prosecutors. Prosecutors at the level of district chief prosecutor will be appointed as grade 1, deputy and chief prosecutors as grade 2, prosecutors with over ten years of experience as grade 3, and those with less than ten years of experience as grade 4 investigators at the SCIA. Regardless of rank, however, everyone will ultimately have their status changed to that of a "judicial police officer."


A 'fruitless' briefing prompts complaints: "Is this job fraud?"


Frontline prosecutors point out a lack of information and poor communication regarding the SCIA. The SCIA’s launch preparation team held closed-door recruitment briefings the day before in regions such as Busan, Changwon, and Gwangju, but attendance was reportedly low as the sessions were not properly announced. A third-year prosecutor commented, "I only received a notice on the fourth, but there was no information on the specific schedule or location. Because information is not being shared, there is even talk that each division should at least send one representative."


During the launch preparation team’s briefing the previous day, a flood of detailed questions arose regarding personnel and working conditions, but the only answer given was "under discussion." To questions regarding long-term rotations for experienced staff or the fate of specialized investigators in areas such as narcotics or digital forensics, the preparation team replied, "Nothing has been finalized yet." To other sensitive questions regarding seniority raises, disadvantages for advancement compared to former police officers, and the size of allowances for major crime cases, the team answered "staffing review is required" and "these matters will be decided after inauguration," failing to provide clear guidelines. According to a prosecutor who attended the briefing, "With everything simply ‘under discussion,’ people are starting to joke that this could become something resembling a job scam."


"Prosecutors Facing Bottleneck and Identity Dilemma in Moving to SCIA" View original image

Ambiguous roles and identity confusion—Concerns over the agency being just a 'resume stopover'


The prosecutors’ lukewarm, if not negative, response is driven by several risks associated with transferring. First, there is a significant mismatch in the rank structure compared to existing prosecutors’ offices. For example, prosecutors with over 10 years’ experience will be given a grade 3 (director-level) post, but there are only 22 such grade 3 positions nationwide (excluding headquarters), setting the stage for a bottleneck in personnel management. An 11th-year prosecutor noted, "Prosecutors with less than 10 years of experience will start as grade 4, and even if they accumulate legal experience, there is no guarantee for promotion to grade 3. In this situation, there’s no incentive to move." One chief prosecutor added, "If the prosecutors with the most investigation experience—those with around 10 years of service—move to grade 3 or grade 4 director-level roles, it will be difficult for them to engage in hands-on investigative work. This will inevitably lead to a sharp decline in investigative quality."


A deputy chief prosecutor stated, "The root meaning of ‘prosecutor’ is to act as a public prosecutor and to secure convictions through indictments; this is the prosecutor’s core identity. If they can only investigate and have to step away before seeing the results in court, there is no difference from the police, which is why few are willing to transfer."



Both inside and outside the legal community, there are concerns that the SCIA may become a "career laundering" stop for those preparing to move to private practice, rather than an agency retaining dedicated long-term personnel. There is a perspective that prosecutors, before opening their own law offices, will merely spend a year or two gathering "SCIA investigative experience" as a credential before leaving the agency.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing