No Progress in Korea-U.S. Talks on Sharing Cleanup Costs
Concerns Over Delays in Nuclear Submarine Projects If Land Disputes Worsen

President Lee’s Special Order: "Resolve U.S. Military Base Land Issues"... Reality Proves a Steep Challenge [Yang Nakkyu’s Defence Club] View original image


The return of U.S. military bases is one of the long-cherished goals of the Lee Jaemyung administration, but the reality is a series of steep challenges. Although President Lee has instructed the Ministry of National Defense to "take a forward-looking approach to resolving issues related to land provided for U.S. military use," this is a matter that requires prior agreement between South Korea and the United States.


The delays in the return of U.S. bases are concentrated in northern Gyeonggi Province. As of last year, there were 50 parcels (15,506,000 square meters) of land in northern Gyeonggi provided to the U.S. military. Among these, 34 parcels (11,256 square meters) have been returned, leaving 16 parcels (4,250 square meters) still awaiting return.


President Lee has been dedicated to the development of these sites in northern Gyeonggi Province since his tenure as governor. In July 2019, during his time as governor, he signed a national-led development agreement for U.S. military-provided land with the cities of Uijeongbu, Paju, and Dongducheon. Later, as the Democratic Party’s 20th presidential candidate in October 2021, he pledged national-led development of the U.S. military-provided land as his first campaign promise. During the Ministry of National Defense work report on August 5, he once again emphasized this issue.


The Ministry of National Defense, along with the Office for Government Policy Coordination, is currently reviewing a variety of options: development through long-term leasing, postpaid payment after lease development, and state-led development. However, even after the U.S. military vacates the bases, follow-up consultations between South Korea and the United States—including environmental contamination assessment, cost-sharing for remediation, and disposal of facilities—must be completed. Without such consultations, it is difficult for local governments to begin development even after receiving the land.


Consultations between South Korea and the United States are a practical challenge. So far, progress has been non-existent and the future schedule remains uncertain. Accumulated tensions over DMZ access rights, U.S. Forces Korea conducting air exercises over the West Sea, and other bilateral frictions have left no room to advance discussions on the U.S. base return issue.


Additionally, if disputes between South Korea and the United States intensify over the return of military bases, this could negatively impact follow-up negotiations on the acquisition of nuclear-powered submarines, broader authority over uranium enrichment and spent nuclear fuel reprocessing, and the implementation of the U.S.-ROK Joint Fact Sheet on security agreements.


However, there is still time. The legal framework has been extended. Last month, the U.S. Base Relocation and Pyeongtaek Support Act was extended for four years, from 2026 to the end of 2030. To facilitate U.S. military relocation, facility construction, and local resident support projects, this law has already been extended three times: in 2011 (effective until 2018), in 2017 (until 2022), and in 2020 (until 2026). Some projects for local development in Pyeongtaek remain unfinished, and follow-up tasks—such as relocating residual facilities in Yongsan, remediating and cleaning up returned land, and securing revenue through land sales—still remain, prompting continued calls for further extension of the law’s validity.



A government official stated, "Northern Gyeonggi Province needs to be addressed with the mindset of 'special compensation for special sacrifices,'" and added, "It is time to move beyond the improvement of regional underdevelopment and to fundamentally reconsider the way we approach policy ideologically."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing